No. XXIX-XXX (2008)
Articles

Learning to Change: Restorative Responses to Wrongdoing

Martin Wright
Restorative Justice Consortium

Published 2008-04-01

Keywords

  • wrongdoing,
  • offenders,
  • restorative justice

How to Cite

Wright, M. (2008). Learning to Change: Restorative Responses to Wrongdoing. Archives of Criminology, (XXIX-XXX), 895–904. https://doi.org/10.7420/AK2007-2008BS

Abstract

The author is looking for the origins of crime in the conflict between those who legally possess power and have access to resources and others, who have no power and are deprived of most of the important resources. He brings up evidence suggesting that the societies with the highest rates of crime are also those with the highest levels of inequality. The author tries to answer two questions: how can crime be prevented(primary prevention) and how can the likelihood of its happening again be reduced (preventing re-offending), in both an effective and ethical way. The author states that the ideal method of preventing the crime is not the threat of potential punishment, but social crime prevention, such as more equitable distribution of material goods, which would encourage people to live a rewarding life without harming others. Further, the author discusses the advantages of the restorative system over the conventional one in terms of ‘preventing re-offending’: focussing on the harm that is caused rather than on the laws that are broken, giving victims a chance to express their fear and needs as well as giving perpetrators the possibility to explain their reasons and express their needs, which enables reflection on how to put everything right and how to engage the community.

References

  1. Bluehouse P., Zion J., Hozhooji naat’aanii. The Navajo Justice and Harmony Ceremony, „Mediation Quarterly” 1993, nr 10(4).
  2. Braithwaite J., Restorative Justice and Responsive Regulation, Oxford University Press New, York-Oxford 2002.
  3. Fisher R., Kopelman E., Schneider A.K., Beyond Machiavelli. Tools for Coping with Conflict, Penguin Books, New York 1996.
  4. Froestad J., Shearing C., Beyond Restorative Justice. Zwelethemba, a Future-Focused Model Using Local Capacity Conflict Resolution [in:] R. Mackay, M. Bošnjak, J. Deklerck, C. Pelikan, B. van Stokkom, M. Wright (eds.), Images of Restorative Justice Theory, Verlag für Polizeiwissenschaft, Frankfurt am Main 2007.
  5. Israeli Supreme Court judgement in criminal appeal 4596/98 Plonit vs. A.G. 54(1), January 2000.
  6. Kellaway R., Brutal! Exposed: Squad of British Soldiers Beat Teenage Iraqis and Shame Their Country, „News of the World” 12 February 2006.
  7. Laurance J., Abused. Bullied. Confined. Drugged. The Scandal of How Britain Cares for Its Most Vulnerable People: The Mentally Disabled, „The Independent” 5 July 2006.
  8. Maksudov R.R., Where Society Must Rein in Government: Restorative Justice and Preservation of Community, unpublished paper.
  9. Porter H., Why I Told Parliament. You’ve Failed Us on Liberty, „Observer” 9 March 2008.
  10. Redekop P., Changing Paradigms: Punishment and Restorative Discipline, Herald Press, Waterloo, Ontario-Scottsdale 2008.
  11. Rosenberg M.B., Speak Peace in a World of Conflict: What You Say Next Will Change Your World, PuddleDancer Press, Encinitas 2005.
  12. Ross R., Returning to the Teachings. Exploring Aboriginal Justice, Penguin Books, Toronto 1996.
  13. Shanin T., Kuda idet Rossiya? [Whither Russia?], Aspect Press, Moscow 1996.
  14. Tutu D., No Future without Forgiveness, Rider, London 1999.
  15. Wilkinson R., Dysfunctional Societies: Why Inequality Matters, paper to conference, Criminal Justice and Social Justice: New Directions, 5-6 July, King’s College, London 2007.
  16. Winter F., Mediation in Neighbourhoods in Wohlers Eichen. A Violence Prevention Project with Emphasis on Integration through Residents’ Participation, Application for Bremen Prize for Integration, 2007.
  17. Wright M., Making Good. Prisons, Punishment and Beyond, Waterside Press, Winchester 2008.
  18. Wright M., Restoring Respect for Justice. A Symposium, 2nd ed., Waterside Press, Winchester 2008.
  19. Wright M., Victim/Offender Mediation as a Step towards a Restorative System of Justice [in:] H. Messmer, H.-U. Otto (ed.), Restorative Justice on Trial: Pitfalls and Potentials of Victim/Offender Mediation − International Research Perspectives, Kluwer, Dordrecht 1992.
  20. Yokoyama M., Analysis of Irresponsible Behaviors in Japanese Corporations, „Kokugakuin Journal” 2006, nr 41(4).
  21. Zehr H., Changing Lenses. A New Focus for Crime and Justice, 2nd ed., Herald Press, Scottsdale 1995.