Opublikowane
17.04.2013
Słowa kluczowe
- recydywa,
- nieletni,
- sprawiedliwość naprawcza,
- mediacje,
- recidivism,
- juvenile,
- restorative justice,
- mediations
...Więcej
Less
Abstrakt
Research on juveniles reoffending, especially in respect to restorative justice practices, are being led in certain countries regularly, in other not. Although the last is rather truth for Poland, longitudinal research on careers of former juveniles participating in mediation has been completed in 2013. Firstly, their reoffending has been checked in 1- 2,5 years period after mediation – then the percentage of reoffending was not high (14,4%), even if compared with research in other countries. Ten years after mediation, about one third (36, 2%) of former juveniles has been punished. Most of this part (40%) has committed single and less serious offense (there was more offenses against property). Only in 10% of the examined group criminality was intensified (however in their case there were risk factors – lack of profession or of work). Drop in number of sentenced persons after 24 year of age confirms the phenomenon of aging-out. Foreign research, even if some were evaluated as fragmentary or methodologically imperfect, are convincing, that taking part in mediation influences desistance, and even if not, less offenses are being committed and of less serious character. Results of Polish research, with two-third of those who succeed to desist offending and with high percentage of less serious offenses may support this thesis, however should be confirmed with more complex evaluation.
Bibliografia
- Bergseth K.J., Bouffard A., Examining the effectiveness of a restorative justice program for various types of juvenile offenders, “International Journal of the Offender Therapy and Comparative Criminology” 2012, vol. 20, iss. 10, pp. 1–22.
- Capdevila Capdevila M., Ferrer Puig M., Recidivism in the Programme of mediation and reparation for minors (executory report), Barcelona 2011, http://www20.gencat.cat/docs/Justicia/Home/%C3%80mbits/Formaci%C3%B3,%20recerca%20i%20docum/Recerca/Cat%C3%A0leg%20d'investigacions/Per%20ordre%20cronol%C3%B2gic/2011/reincidencia_programa_mediacio/reincidencia_program_mediacio_inform_executiu_ang.pdf [accessed: 24.10.2003].
- Chapman T., Restorative Justice in Northern Ireland: Conflict and Accommodation, unpublished presentation.
- Dünkel F., Germany, [in:] F. Dünkel, J. Grzywa, P. Horsfield, I. Prin (eds.), Juvenile Justice Systems in Europe, Forum-Verlag Godesberg, Mönchengladbach 2010.
- Dünkel F., Pruin I., Grzywa J., Sanctions systems and trends in the development of sentencing practices, with further references, [in:] F. Dünkel, J. Grzywa, P. Horsfield, I. Prin (eds.), Juvenile Justice Systems in Europe, Forum-Verlag Godesberg, Mönchengladbach 2010.
- Forsythe L., An Analysis of Juvenile Apprehension Characteristics and Reapprehension Rates.
- Herman L., Strang H., Restorative Justice. The Evidence, The Smith Institute, London 2007.
- Kołakowska-Przełomiec H., Wójcik D., Selekcja nieletnich przestępców w sądach rodzinnych, Zakład Narodowy im. Ossolińskich, Warszawa, Wrocław 1990.
- Livingstone N., Macdonald G., Car N., Restorative justice conferencing for reducing recidivism in young offenders (aged 7 to 21), “Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews” 2013, iss. 2, DOI: 10.1002/14651858.CD008898.pub2 [accessed: 24.10.2013].
- Marshall T.F., Merry S., Crime and Accountability, London, HMSO 1990.
- Ostrihanska Z., Wójcik D., Młodzież nieprzystosowana społecznie (badania katamnestyczne), „Archiwum Kryminologii” 1960, t. 1, pp. 141–188.
- Pelikan Ch., Victim-offender mediation in Austria, [in:] Victim-Offender Mediation in Europe. Making Restorative Justice Work, Leuven University Press, Leuven 2000, pp. 148–149.
- Restorative Justice and Crime Prevention. Presenting a Theoretical Exploration, an Empirical Analysis and the Policy Perspective, April 2010, http://euforumrj.org/assets/upload/Restorative_Justice_and_Crime_Prevention_Final_report.pdf [accessed: 24.10.2013].
- Rudrick R., A court-referrred scheme, [in:] M. Wright, B. Gallaway (ed.), Mediation and Criminal Justice: Victims, Offenders and Community, Sage Publications, London 1989.
- Rzeplinska I., Kariery kryminalne nieletnich skazanych w warunkach art. 10 par. 2 kk, [w:] A. Michalska-Warias, I. Nowikowski, J. Piórkowska-Flieger (ed.), Teoretyczne i praktyczne problemy współczesnego prawa karnego. Księga jubileuszowa dedykowana Profesorowi Tadeuszowi Bojarskiemu, Lublin 2011, pp. 749–753.
- Rzeplińska I., Sylwetki społeczne nieletnich – późniejszych dorosłych sprawców przestępstw, „Archiwum Kryminologii” 2009, t. 29–30, pp. 409–415.
- Schulz H., Die Rückfallhäufigkeit nach einem Ausergerichtlichen Tatsausgleich bei Erwachsenen.
- The IJJO at the International Expert Consultation on Restorative Justice for Children, Friday 26th of July 2013, http://www.oijj.org/en/news/ijjo-day-by-day/the-ijjo-at-the-international-expert-consultation-onrestorative-justice-for-ch [accessed: 24.10.2013].
- Unell J., Leming A., An Evaluation of The Mediation and Reparation Schemes in Coventry and Wolverhampton, Unpublished Report to Home Office, London 1988.
- Wartna B.S.J., Nijssen L.T.J., National Studies on Recidivism. An Inventory of Large-Scale Recidivism Research in 33 European Countries, WODC 2006.
- Weiterkamp E.G.M., Research on victim-offender mediation. Finding and needs for the future, [in:] Victim-Offender Mediation in Europe. Making Restorative Justice Work, Leuven University Press, Leuven 2000.
- Woźniakowska-Fajst D., Nieletnie dziewczęta 10 lat później – badania katamnestyczne, „Archiwum Kryminologii” 2011, t. 13, pp. 163–195.
