Guidelines for authors
Procedure for accepting and reviewing articles in the Bulletin of Criminology
1 Submission of articles to the Bulletin of Criminology
1.1 Articles for the Bulletin of Criminology may be submitted in response to an individual invitation from the journal’s editorial board, in response to a public call for submissions, or on the author’s initiative.
1.2 All texts shall be sent electronically by the form on the journal’s website.
1.3 All submitted articles must be scholarly and must be prepared according to the following guidelines:
1.3.1. the text should not exceed a volume of approximately 100,000 characters with spaces;
1.3.2. the text should be accompanied by an abstract (a maximum of 1,500 characters with spaces) and 3–7 keywords. The title, abstract, and keywords should be included in both Polish and English;
1.3.3. the author is obliged to provide his/her affiliation, title/degree, e-mail address, and ORCID number; and
1.3.4. in those cases where the submitted text contains tables or graphs prepared in a format other than Microsoft Word (e.g., MS Excel), the source file of such a table or graph must also be submitted separately from the article text.
1.4 Texts are published in both Polish and English.
Texts sent after the deadline for the submission of articles shall not be considered for further editorial work within a given issue of the Bulletin of Criminology, unless the submission of an article after the deadline has been previously agreed with the editorial office. The editors, after obtaining the author’s consent, may also decide to move them to the next issue of the journal.
1.5 Unsolicited texts are subject to preliminary review by the editorial office, which decides whether to send them for review or reject them.
2 Prohibition of ghostwriting
By submitting a text, the author declares that it has not been previously published or submitted for print anywhere. Texts previously published elsewhere or submitted elsewhere for publication will not be published in the Bulletin of Criminology.
The author also declares that they are the author or co-author(s) of the text and that all co-authors have been listed.
The author must indicate if any artificial intelligence (AI) tools were used during the preparation of the article, including in the research on which the article is based. If so, disclose how they were used and name those tools.
3 Artificial Intelligence (AI) Policy
3.1 Artificial Intelligence (AI) or AI-assisted tools may support creative processes, but authors are responsible for the final content and form of the manuscript.
3.2 The use of AI-based tools to support drafting the manuscript should be limited solely to the purposes of proofreading and readability enhancement. These tools should not replace the author's independent creative process and should not be considered an author. If authors have used AI in the research process, its use should be described in detail in the research methodology in the main body of the paper.
3.3 Any use of AI in the writing or review process must be reduced to a minimum and clearly declared in a dedicated statement to ensure transparency and compliance with the ethical policy.
3.4 The use of AI or AI-assisted tools in the process of generating primary graphic materials for publication is permitted. The use of the aforementioned tools to modify, transform, or otherwise process existing visual, photographic, or graphic works protected by copyright and related rights is prohibited.
3.5 Authors are required to disclose the use of AI or AI-assisted tools at the submission stage by completing a dedicated disclosure statement, including the full name of the tool used, the precise manner and scope of its use, and the nature of its impact on the final text. If the manuscript is accepted for publication, the content of this statement will be included in the published manuscript.
4 Acceptance of an Article for Publication
4.1 The article is accepted for publication if both reviews are positive.
4.1.1. If the reviewers have found that changes or additions need to be made to the text, then publication is conditional on the author making the changes to the article.
4.1.2. If the article receives two different reviews (positive and negative), the editors will decide whether to reject the article or to appoint another reviewer.
4.1.3 If the author receives two negative reviews, the text is rejected.
4.2 Each article accepted for publication undergoes linguistic and editorial correction.
5 Final remarks
5.1 The Editorial Board does not return submitted materials to their authors.
5.2 The editors may refuse to publish the text without giving reasons.
5.3 The editors do not pay for the published texts.
5.4 The editors do not pay for reviews.