Vol. 42 (2022)
Special section

The Russian “Special Military Operation” in Ukraine Before International Courts

Anna Wyrozumska
University of Łódź

Published 2023-06-30

Keywords

  • use of force,
  • international courts,
  • aggression in Ukraine,
  • Russia and the ECHR,
  • ECtHR,
  • genocide,
  • ICC investigation

How to Cite

Wyrozumska, A. (2023). The Russian “Special Military Operation” in Ukraine Before International Courts. Polish Yearbook of International Law, 42, 9–32. https://doi.org/10.24425/PYIL.2023.147167

Abstract

Following the so-called “special military operation”, which was in fact an open aggression against Ukraine, Russia was expelled from the Council of Europe. This step has significant legal consequences, including for the jurisdiction of the European Court of Human Rights. Meanwhile, many individual applications were filed with the Court, and Ukraine brought an inter-State complaint against Russia. Ukraine has also triggered the International Court of Justice. The Court has already ordered provisional measures. The ICC Prosecutor has launched an investigation into the most serious international crimes, war crimes, crimes against humanity, and genocide in Ukraine and delivered arrest warrants against the Russian President and his Com­missioner for Children’s Rights. There is a serious discussion going on concerning the establishment of a special tribunal for the crime of aggression. This text deals with some aspects of the Russian “special military operation” cases before international courts. It attempts to identify what role the international courts may play in the new phase of the conflict in Ukraine and the extent and effect of their intervention, given the jurisdictional limitations and the inability to enforce judgments.

References

  1. Blanco M., A Backdoor Exit from the European Convention on Human Rights: Russia, the Council of Europe and Article 58(3) ECHR, Verfassungsblog, 5 April 2022, available at: https://bit.ly/3AzEBW8 (accessed 30 April 2023).
  2. Borjas D.S., The ICJ Order in Ukraine v. Russia: Quo Vadis?, Völkerrechtsblog, 28 March 2022, available at: https://voelkerrechtsblog.org/the-icj-order-in-ukraine-v-russia/ (accessed 30 April 2023).
  3. Burbano Herrera C., Haeck Y., Letting States off the Hook? The Paradox of the Legal Consequences following State Non-compliance with Provisional Measures in the Inter-American and European Human Rights Systems, 28(3) Netherlands Quarterly of Human Rights 332 (2010).
  4. Coracini A.R., Is Amending the Rome Statute the Panacea Against Perceived Selectivity and Impunity for the Crime of Aggression Committed Against Ukraine? Just Security, 21 March 2023, available at: https://bit.ly/3oI8Bwe (accessed 30 April 2023).
  5. Demir-Gürsel E., The Council of Europe’s Sharp Turn: Russia’s Expulsion and its Possible Implications for Other Member States, Verfassungsblog, 25 March 2022, available at: https://voelkerrechtsblog.org/fromgrey-zones-to-red-lines/ (accessed 30 April 2023).
  6. Dzehtsiarou K., Georgia v. Russia II, 115(2) American Journal of International Law 288 (2021), pp. 288-294.
  7. ECtHR (GC), Fedotova and Others v. Russia (App. Nos. 40792/10, 30538/14 and 43439/14), 17 January 2023.
  8. ECtHR, De Wilde Ooms and Versyp (“Vagrancy”) v. Belgium (App. Nos. 2832/66; 2835/66; 2899/66), 18 June 1971.
  9. Forde A., From Grey Zones to Red Lines: Implications of the Ukraine Conflict on Europe’s Human Rights System, Völkerrechtsblog, 1 March 2022, available at: https://voelkerrechtsblog.org/from-grey-zones-to-redlines/ (accessed 30 April 2023).
  10. Hathaway O., The Case for Creating an International Tribunal to Prosecute the Crime of Aggression Against Ukraine, An agreement between the United Nations and Ukraine can pave the way, Just Security, 20 September 2022, available at: https://www.justsecurity.org/83117/the-case-for-creating-an-international-tribunal-to-prosecute-the-crime-of-aggressionagainst-ukraine/ (accessed 30 April 2023).
  11. ICC participates in joint investigation team supported by Eurojust on alleged core international crimes in Ukraine, available at: https://www.eurojust.europa.eu/news/icc-participates-joint-investigation-team-supportedeurojust-alleged-core-international-crimes (accessed 30 April 2023).
  12. ICC, Press Release 17 March 2023, available at: https://www.icc-cpi.int/news/situation-ukraine-iccjudges-issue-arrest-warrants-against-vladimir-vladimirovich-putin-and (accessed 30 April 2023).
  13. ICC-01/22 Situation in Ukraine, available at: https://www.icc-cpi.int/situations/ukraine (accessed 30 April 2023).
  14. ICJ judgment of 8 November 2019, Application of the International Convention for the Suppression of the Financing of Terrorism and of the International Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Racial Discrimination (Ukraine v. Russian Federation), Judgment, Preliminary Objections, ICJ Rep 2019.
  15. ICJ, Allegations of Genocide under the Convention on the Prevention and Punishment of the Crime of Genocide (Ukraine v. Russian Federation), Order, 16 March 2022.
  16. ICJ, Arrest Warrant of 11 April 2000 (Democratic Republic of the Congo v. Belgium), Judgment, 14 February 2002.
  17. ICJ, Case Concerning Application of the Convention on the Prevention and Punishment of the Crime of Genocide (Bosnia and Herzegovina v. Serbia and Montenegro), Judgment, 26 February 2007, ICJ Rep 2007.
  18. ICJ, Judgment of 24 February 1982, Case Concerning the Continental Shelf (Tunisia v. Libyan Arab Jamahiriya), ICJ Rep 1982.
  19. Istrefi K., Buyse A., Strasbourg Court issues interim measures against Turkey regarding the Nagorno- Karabakh conflict, ECHR Blog, 7 October 2020, available at: https://bit.ly/3LC3AOK (accessed 30 April 2023).
  20. Jordan P.A., Russia’s Accession to the Council of Europe and Compliance with European Human Rights Norms, Demokratizatsiya 2003, available at: https://demokratizatsiya.pub/archives/11-2_ Jordan.PDF (accessed 30 April 2023).
  21. Komarow A., Hathaway O., Ukraine’s Constitutional Constraints: How to Achieve Accountability for the Crime of Aggression, Just Security, 6 April 2022, available at: https://www.justsecurity.org/80958/ukraines-constitutional-constraintshow-to-achieve-accountability-for-the-crime-of-aggression/ (accessed 30 April 2023).
  22. Kranz J., Ukraina ma dobre karty w sporze z Rosją przed Międzynarodowym Trybunałem Sprawiedliwości. Zarządzenie Trybunału z 16 marca 2022 r. w sprawie środków tymczasowych [Ukraine has good cards in its dispute with Russia before the International Court of Justice. Order of the Court of 16 March 2022 on provisional measures], Monitor Konstytucyjny, 18 March 2022, available at: https://monitorkonstytucyjny.eu/archiwa/21401 (accessed 30 April 2023).
  23. Kremlin Rejects Top UN Court’s Order to Halt Ukraine Invasion, The Moscow Times, 17 March 2022, available at: https://www.themoscowtimes.com/2022/03/17/kremlin-rejects-top-un-courts-orderto-halt-ukraine-invasion-a76975 (accessed 30 April 2023).
  24. Kreß C., Hobe S., Nußberger A., The Ukraine War and the Crime of Aggression: How to Fill the Gaps in the International Legal System, Just Security, 23 January 2023, available at: https://www.justsecurity.org/84783/the-ukraine-war-and-the-crime-of-aggression-how-to-fill-the-gaps-in-the-international-legalsystem/ (accessed 30 April 2023).
  25. Kreß C., The Ukraine War and the Prohibition of the Use of Force in International Law, TOAEP, Occasional Paper Series No. 13 (2022).
  26. LaGrand case (Germany v. United States of America), Judgment, ICJ Rep 2001.
  27. Leach P., Ukraine, Russia and Crimea in the European Court of Human Rights, EJIL: Talk!, 19 March 2014, available at: https://bit.ly/3oUhpiY (accessed 30 April 2023).
  28. Legal and human rights aspects of the Russian Federation’s aggression against Ukraine, Resolution 2482 (2023), 26 January 2023, available at: https://pace.coe.int/en/files/31620/html (accessed 30 April 2023).
  29. Measures to be taken, including under Article 8 of the Statute of the Council of Europe, 25 February 2022, CM/Del/Dec(2022)1426ter/2.3.
  30. Milanovic M., ICJ Indicates Provisional Measures Against Russia, in a Near Total Win for Ukraine; Russia Expelled from the Council of Europe, EJIL: Talk!, 16 March 2022, available at: https://bit.ly/3HdfwEa (accessed 30 April 2023).
  31. Nuridzhanian G., Ukraine v. Russia in International Courts and Tribunals, EJIL: Talk!, 9 March 2016, available at: https://www.ejiltalk.org/ukraine-versus-russia-in-international-courts-and-tribunals/ (accessed 30 April 2023).
  32. Parliamentarians for Global Action, Buenos Aires Plan of Action on the Universality and Effectiveness of, and political support for, the Rome Statute system against impunity, 4–5 November 2022, available at: https://www.pgaction.org/pdf/annual-forum/2022/buenos-aires-poa-2022-en.pdf (accessed 30 April 2023).
  33. President’s Office opposes “hybrid tribunal” on Russia’s crime of aggression, Ukrainska Pravda, 17 February 2023, available at: https://www.pravda.com.ua/eng/news/2023/02/17/7389799/ (accessed 30 April 2023).
  34. Resolution on the cessation of the membership of the Russian Federation to the Council of Europe, 16 March 2022, CM/Res(2022)2.
  35. Risini I., Human Rights in the Line of Fire: Georgia v. Russia (II) Before the European Court of Human Rights, Verfassungsblog, 28 January 2021, available at: https://verfassungsblog.de/human-rights-in-the-line-of-fire/ (accessed 30 April 2023).
  36. Russian Federation, available at: https://www.icj-cij.org/sites/default/files/case-related/182/182-20220307-OTH-01-00-EN.pdf (accessed 30 April 2023).
  37. Secretary General of the Council of Europe, available at: https://www.coe.int/en/web/portal/-/statement-by-council-of-europe-secretary-general-marija-pejcinovicburic-on-the-recognition-of-the-so-called-people-s-republics-of-donetsk-and-luhan-1 (accessed 30 April 2023).
  38. Situation in Ukraine, CM/Del/Dec(2022)1426bis/2.3, 24 February 2022.
  39. Speech by the President of Ukraine at the General Debate of the 77th session of the UN General Assembly, available at: https://www.legal-tools.org/doc/wh08nu/ (accessed 30 April 2023).
  40. Statement calling for the creation of a Special Tribunal for the Punishment of the crime of aggression against Ukraine, 4 March 2022, available at: https://gordonandsarahbrown.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/03/Combined-Statement-and-Declaration.pdf (accessed 30 April 2023).
  41. Statement of ICC Prosecutor, Karim A.A. Khan QC, at the Arria-Formula meeting of the UN Security Council on Ensuring accountability for atrocities committed in Ukraine, 27 April 2022, available at: https://www.icc-cpi.int/news/statement-icc-prosecutor-karim-aa-khan-qc-arria-formula-meeting-unsecurity-council-ensuring (accessed 30 April 2023).
  42. Statement of ICC Prosecutor, Karim A.A. Khan QC, on the Situation in Ukraine, 25 February 2022, available at: https://www.icc-cpi.int/news/statement-icc-prosecutor-karim-aa-khan-qc-situation-ukraine-ihave-been-closely-following (accessed 30 April 2023).
  43. Statement of ICC Prosecutor, Karim A.A. Khan QC, on the Situation in Ukraine, 28 February 2022, available at: https://www.icc-cpi.int/news/statement-icc-prosecutor-karim-aa-khan-qc-situation-ukraine-ihave-decided-proceed-opening (accessed 30 April 2023).
  44. Strengthening International Law in Times of Crisis, speech by German Foreign Minister Annalena Baerbock in The Hague, 16 January 2023, available at: https://www.auswaertiges-amt.de/de/newsroom/strengthening-international-law-in-times-of-crisis/25733 (accessed 30 April 2023).
  45. The Common Plan or Conspiracy and Aggressive War, available at: https://avalon.law.yale.edu/subject_menus/15th.asp (accessed 30 April 2023).
  46. Trahan J., Don’t be Fooled By U.S. Smoke and Mirrors on the Crime of Aggression, Weak Proposals Carry the Risk of Weak Results, Just Security, 14 April 2023, available at: https://www.justsecurity.org/85986/dont-be-fooled-by-u-s-smoke-and-mirrors-on-thecrime-of-aggression/ (both accessed 30 April 2023).
  47. Tzevelekos V.P., On the value of interim measures by the ECtHR on inter-state disputes, Strasbourg Observers, 3 February 2021, available at: https://bit.ly/3n51o9j (accessed 30 April 2023).
  48. UK Government Press Release, 20 January 2023, available at: https://www.gov.uk/government/news/ukraine-uk-joins-core-group-dedicated-to-achieving-accountability-for-russias-aggression-against-ukraine (accessed 30 April 2023).
  49. Venice Commission, Amendments to the Federal Constitutional Law on the Constitutional Court of the Russian Federation, Opinion No. 832/2015, CDL-REF(2016)006, Strasbourg, 20 January 2016.