Make a Submission
Vol. 43 (2023)
Special section

Prosecution of the Crime of Aggression in International and Ukrainian Jurisdiction: Challenges and Prospects

PDF
  • Anton Korynevych,
  • Oksana Senatorova,
  • Mykhaylo Shepitko
Anton Korynevych
National Taras Shevchenko University, Ukraine
Oksana Senatorova
National University of Kyiv-Mohyla Academy, Ukraine
Mykhaylo Shepitko
Department of Criminal Law, Yaroslav Mudryi National Law University, Ukraine

Published 2024-06-25

Keywords

  • crime of aggression,
  • criminal law of Ukraine,
  • domestic jurisdiction,
  • ICC,
  • international criminal law,
  • Russian aggression against Ukraine
    • ...More
    Less

How to Cite

Prosecution of the Crime of Aggression in International and Ukrainian Jurisdiction: Challenges and Prospects. (2024). Polish Yearbook of International Law, 43, 367–379. https://doi.org/10.24425/pyil.2024.152308

Abstract

This article explores the genesis of Russian aggression against Ukraine, tracing its origins from the unprovoked illegal invasion initiated in February 2014 to the full-scale invasion in 2022. Despite initial international responses, the lack of significant sanctions against Russia or efforts to prosecute its leaders for the crime of aggression persisted until the 2022 invasion. The international community’s condemnation of the brutality accompanying this invasion underscored the need for accountability mechanisms within the existing international legal framework. However, limitations in prosecuting aggression within the International Criminal Court, coupled with challenges in amending the Rome Statute, have led to proposals for an ad hoc mechanism to address aggression gaining traction. These proposals highlight the urgency of holding aggressors accountable and safeguarding victims’ rights. Concurrently, Ukrainian jurisdiction incorporates the concept of the crime of aggression in its Criminal Code but lacks clarity on essential elements necessary for prosecuting such crimes, including the leadership element. An analysis of court verdicts reveals discrepancies in interpreting the crime of aggression, emphasising the necessity of adopting a unified approach that is consistent with international law. The article underscores the critical importance of enhancing legal frameworks, building capacity and encouraging international cooperation to ensure accountability for the crime of aggression and to preserve the rule of law.

PDF

References

  1. Ambassador Van Schaack’s Remarks on the U.S. Proposal to Prosecute Russian Crimes of Aggression Remarks, U.S. Department of State, 27 March 2023, available at: https://www.state.gov/ambassador-vanschaacks-remarks/ (accessed 30 August 2024).
  2. Analytical Guide to the Work of the International Law Commission, Peremptory Norms of General International Law (Jus Cogens), International Law Commission, available at: https://legal.un.org/ilc/guide/1_14.shtml (accessed 30 August 2024).
  3. Appeal of MEPs in support of the ICC Prosecutor to proceed with opening an investigation into the situation in Ukraine and to the States Parties to the Rome Statute of the ICC – including all EU Member States – to provide effective support to the ICC and align the jurisdiction on the crime of aggression to the other international crimes, Brussels, 4 March 2022, available at: https://www.pgaction.org/pdf/2022/mep-ukraine-appeal.pdf (accessed 30 August 2024).
  4. Austrian Government Erläuterungen der Regierungsvorlage, ErläutRV 689 BlgNR XXV, 2015.
  5. Corten O., Koutroulis V., Tribunal for the Crime of Aggression Against Ukraine: A Legal Assessment, European Parliament, Strasbourg: 2022, available at: https://tinyurl.com/2s4awayk (accessed 30 August 2024).
  6. Crane D.M., Considerations for the Setting Up of the Special Tribunal for Ukraine on the Crime of Aggression, Global Accountability Network, July 2022, available at: https://tinyurl.com/mwsyd49m (accessed 30 August 2024).
  7. Declaration on Standing with Ukraine, Vilnius, 30 May 2022.
  8. Draft Act on Amendments to Certain Legislative Acts of Ukraine on the Implementation of International Criminal and Humanitarian Law of 27 December 2019, No. 2689, available at: https://w1.c1.rada.gov.ua/pls/zweb2/webproc4_1?pf3511=67804 (accessed 30 August 2024).
  9. Draft Act on Amendments to the Criminal Code of Ukraine and the Criminal Procedure Code of Ukraine, of 15 March 2022, No. 7290, available at: https://w1.c1.rada.gov.ua/pls/zweb2/webproc4_1?pf3511=74105 (accessed 30 August 2024).
  10. Draft conclusions on identifcation and legal consequences of peremptory norms of general international law (jus cogens), available at: https://legal.un.org/ilc/texts/instruments/english/draft_articles/1_14_2022.pdf (accessed 30 August 2024).
  11. ECtHR, Ukraine and the Netherlands v. Russia (App. No. 43800/14, 8019/16 and 28525/20), 30 November 2022.
  12. ECtHR, Ukraine v. Russia (re Crimea) (App. No. 20958/14 and 38334/18), 14 December 2020.
  13. Ferencz B.B., Can Aggression Be Deterred by Law?, 11 Pace International Law Review 341 (1999), pp. 341–360.
  14. Ghaedi M., Romaniec R., Germany’s Baerbock calls for special Ukraine tribunal at ICC, Deutsche Welle, 16 January 2023, available at: https://www.dw.com/en/germanys-baerbock-calls-for-special-ukrainetribunal-at-icc/a-64408862 (accessed 30 August 2024).
  15. Government of Liechtenstein, Bericht und Antrag an den Landtag des Fürstentums Liechtenstein betreffend die Abänderung des Strafgesetzbuches, der Strafprozessordnung, des Gesetzes über die Zusammenarbeit mit dem Internationalen Strafgerichtshof und anderen Internationalen Gerichten sowie des Naturschutzgesetzes, No. 90/2018, 9 October 2018.
  16. Grant T.D., Expelling Russia From the UN Security Council – A How-to Guide, CEPA, 26 September 2022, available at: https://cepa.org/article/expelling-russia-from-the-un-security-council-a-how-to-guide/ (accessed 30 August 2024).
  17. Grzebyk P., Crime of Aggression Against Ukraine: The Role of Regional Customary Law, 2021 (3) Journal of International Criminal Justice 435 (2023), pp. 435–459.
  18. Hajdin N., The Leadership Clause in the Crime of Aggression and its Customary International Law Status, Just Security, 17 March 2022, available at: https://tinyurl.com/58nnw6vy (accessed 30 August 2024).
  19. Hartig A., Making Aggression a Crime Under Domestic Law: On the Legislative Implementation of Article 8bis of the ICC Statute, T.M.C. Asser Press, Hague: 2023.
  20. Hernandez M., Gettleman J., O’Reilly F., Wallace T., What Ukraine Has Lost During Russia’s Invasion, The New York Times, 3 June 2024, available at: https://tinyurl.com/4ys9uawe (accessed 30 August 2024).
  21. Homepage, Prosecutor General’s Ofce, available at: https://gp.gov.ua/ (accessed 30 August 2024).
  22. HRC, General comment No. 36 (2018) on article 6 of the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights, on the right to life, 3 September 2019, CCPR/C/GC/36.
  23. ICC, Situation in Ukraine, ICC-01/22, 2 March 2022, available at: https://www.icc-cpi.int/situations/ukraine (accessed 30 August 2024).
  24. ICJ, Allegations of Genocide Under the Convention on the Prevention and Punishment of the Crime of Genocide (Ukraine v. Russian Federation), Judgment, 2 February 2024, ICJ Rep 2024.
  25. ICJ, Application of the International Convention for the Suppression of the Financing of Terrorism and of the International Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Racial Discrimination (Ukraine v. Russian Federation), Judgment, 8 November 2019, ICJ Rep 2019.
  26. Immunities and a Special Tribunal for the Crime of Aggression Against Ukraine, International Renaissance Foundation, Kyiv: 2023, available at: https://tinyurl.com/ax6vbrbh (accessed 30 August 2024).
  27. International Centre for the Prosecution of the Crime of Aggression Against Ukraine (Lectue at EuroJust), available at: https://tinyurl.com/4uzh8tm3 (accessed 30 August 2024).
  28. It is Only a Full-Fledged Tribunal That Will Allow Lifting the Immunity of the President, Prime Minister and Foreign Minister of Russia – Andriy Smyrnov, President of Ukraine, 1 February 2024, available at: https://tinyurl.com/3nmhdpk5 (accessed 30 August 2024).
  29. ITLOS, Case Concerning the Detention of Three Ukrainian Naval Vessels (Ukraine v. Russian Federation), Provisional Measures, No. 26 (2019).
  30. Janowski K., Civilian Deaths In Ukraine War Top 10,000, UN Says, United Nations Ukraine, 21 November 2023, available at: https://ukraine.un.org/en/253322-civilian-deaths-ukraine-war-top-10000-un-says (accessed 30 August 2024).
  31. Johnson L.D., United Nations Response Options to Russia’s Aggression: Opportunities and Rabbit Holes, Just Security, 1 March 2022, available at: https://tinyurl.com/wfpwa54x (accessed 30 August 2024).
  32. Joint Motion for a Resolution 2022/3017(RSP) of 18 January 2023 on the Establishment of a Tribunal on the Crime of Aggression Against Ukraine.
  33. Joint Statement on Efforts to Establish a Tribunal on the Crime of Aggression Against Ukraine, Ministry of Foreign Affairs of Ukraine, 9 May 2023, available at: https://tinyurl.com/mn85w3s8 (accessed 30 August 2024).
  34. Kelsen H., General Theory of Law and State, The Lawbook Exchange, Clark: 1999.
  35. Kress C., Hobe S., Nußberger A., The Ukraine War and the Crime of Aggression: How to Fill the Gaps in the International Legal System, Just Security, 23 January 2023, available at: https://tinyurl.com/26hdw6e2 (accessed 30 August 2024).
  36. Kreß C., On the Activation of ICC Jurisdiction Over the Crime of Aggression, 16(1) Journal of International Criminal Justice 1 (2018), pp. 1–17.
  37. Kruk K., The Crimean Factor: How the European Union Reacted to Russia’s Annexation of Crimea, Warsaw Institute Review, 7 May 2019, available at: https://warsawinstitute.org/crimean-factor-european-union-reacted-russias-annexation-crimea/ (accessed 30 August 2024).
  38. Lau S., “We Told you So!” How the West Didn’t Listen to the Countries that Know Russia Best, Politico, 9 March 2022, available at: https://www.politico.eu/article/western-europe-listen-to-the-baltic-countriesthat-know-russia-best-ukraine-poland/ (accessed 30 August 2024).
  39. List of suspects in the main case of “24th February”,Prosecutor General’s Ofce, available at: https://gp.gov.ua/detectable (accessed 30 August 2024).
  40. McDougall C., The Imperative of Prosecuting Crimes of Aggression Committed Against Ukraine, 28(2) Journal of Conflict and Security Law 203 (2023), pp. 203–230.
  41. Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe, Report 15842 (2023): Ensuring a just peace in Ukraine and lasting security in Europe, available at: https://pace.coe.int/en/fles/33074/html (accessed 30 August 2024).
  42. Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe, Resolution 2132 (2016): Political consequences of the Russian aggression in Ukraine, available at: https://tinyurl.com/4hppmhxr (accessed 30 August 2024).
  43. Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe, Resolution 2433 (2022): Consequences of the Russian Federation’s continued aggression against Ukraine: Role and response of the Council of Europe.
  44. Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe, Resolution 2482 (2023): Legal and Human Rights Aspects of the Russian Federation’s Aggression Against Ukraine, available at: https://pace.coe.int/en/fles/31620/html (accessed 20 August 2024).
  45. PCA, Dispute Concerning Coastal State Rights in the Black Sea, Sea of Azov, and Kerch Strait (Ukraine v. the Russian Federation), No. 2017-06.
  46. Postanova VP VS vìd 28 lûtogo 2024 roku u spravì No. 415/2182/20 (provadžennâ No. 13-15x22), available at: https://reyestr.court.gov.ua/Review/117555176 (accessed 30 August 2024).
  47. Proposal to Amend the Rome Statute Kampala Amendment on the Crime of Aggression, Parliamentarians for Global Action, 20 February 2023, available at: https://tinyurl.com/3v4unmyd (accessed 30 August 2024).
  48. Putinpriznal “nezavisimostʹ” Hersonskoj i Zaporožskoj oblastej Ukrainy. Ètoformalʹnostʹ dlâ ih ann [Putin recognized the “independence” of the Kherson and Zaporozhye regions of Ukraine. This is a formality for their annexation], BBC News Russia, 29 September 2022, available at: https://www.bbc.com/russian/news-63084494 (accessed 30 August 2024).
  49. Ragazzi M., The Concept of International Obligations Erga Omnes, Oxford University Press, Oxford: 2010.
  50. Report on Preliminary Examination Activities 2020, International Criminal Court, Den Haag: 2020, available at: https://tinyurl.com/54ctx47z (accessed 30 August 2024).
  51. Resolution 2014/2627(RSP) of 13 March 2014 on the Invasion of Ukraine by Russia.
  52. Resolution 2022/3017(RSP) of 19 January 2023 on the Establishment of a Tribunal on the Crime of Aggression Against Ukraine.
  53. Resolution of 2–6 July 2022 on the Russian Federation’s War of Aggression Against Ukraine and its People, and its Threat to Security Across the OSCE Region, AS (22) D E.
  54. Russia’s invasion places a generation of Ukrainian children under severe strain, The UN Refugee Agency Ukraine, 31 May 2024, available at: https://tinyurl.com/56kprmpy (accessed 30 August 2024).
  55. Russia’s War Crimes site, War Ukraine, available at: https://war.ukraine.ua/russia-war-crimes (accessed 30 August 2024).
  56. Russian Federation Invasion of Ukraine Bringing New Bloodshed, Suffering, Global Food Insecurity, Instability, Secretary-Tells Global Crisis Response Group, United Nations, 8 June 2022, available at: https://press.un.org/en/2022/sgsm21314.doc.htm (accessed 30 August 2024).
  57. Sands P., Russian President’s Use of Military Force is a Crime of Aggression, Financial Times, 1 March 2022, available at: https://tinyurl.com/2mstfkwj (accessed 30 August 2024).
  58. Sayapin S., A Curious Aggression Trial in Ukraine: Some Reflections on the Alexandrov and Yerofeyev Case, 16(5) Journal of International Criminal Justice 1093 (2018), pp. 1093–1104.
  59. Sayapin S., The Yanukovych Trial in Ukraine: A Revival of the Crime of Aggression?, 50 Israel Yearbook on Human Rights 63 (2020), pp. 63–79.
  60. Senatorova O., Bringing Aggressors to Justice, Deutsche Welle, 10 May 2023, available at: https://issuu.com/deutsche-welle/docs/dw-weltzeit_2023 (accessed 30 August 2024).
  61. Senatorova O., Deportation von Ukrainern seit Beginn der russischen Invasion – völkerrechtliche Einordnung und Empfehlungen, Ukraine verstehen, Analyse, 17 March 2023, available at: https://tinyurl.com/2nfrdekj (accessed 30 August 2024).
  62. Senatorova O., Welche Rolle ein “Sondertribunal zum Verbrechen der Aggression gegen die Ukraine” für die Opfer des Krieges spielen könnte, 272 Aus Ukraine-Analysen 7 (2022), pp. 7–12, available at: https://laender-analysen.de/ukraine-analysen/autoren/oksana-senatorova (accessed 30 August 2024).
  63. Shashkova M., “Putin and His Doppelgängers Must Be Tried at a War Crimes Tribunal” – Deputy Head of Zelensky’s Ofce, Kyiv Post, 16 March 2023, available at: https://www.kyivpost.com/post/14386 (accessed 30 August 2024).
  64. Situation in Ukraine: ICC Judges Issue Arrest Warrants Against Vladimir Vladimirovich Putin and Maria Alekseyevna Lvova-Belova, International Criminal Court, 17 March 2023, available at: https://www.icc-cpi.int/news/situation-ukraine-icc-judges-issue-arrest-warrants-against-vladimir-vladimirovich-putinand (accessed 30 August 2024).
  65. Statement on Russia’s Invasion of Ukraine: A Crime of Aggression of 24 March 2022, The Need to Amend the Crime of Aggression’s Jurisdictional Regime, available at: https://tinyurl.com/mr3ep8n7 (accessed 30 August 2024).
  66. UK Joins Core Group Dedicated to Achieving Accountability for Russia’s Aggression Against Ukraine, Gov.UK, 20 January 2023, available at: https://tinyurl.com/58663e2k (accessed 30 August 2024).
  67. UNGA resolution of 14 December 1974, Defnition of aggression, Doc. A/RES/3314.
  68. UNGA resolution of 14 November 2022, Furtherance of remedy and reparation for aggression against Ukraine, Doc. A/RES/ES-11/5.
  69. UNGA resolution of 16 February 2023, Principles of the Charter of the United Nations underlying a comprehensive, just and lasting peace in Ukraine, Doc. A/RES/ES-11/6.
  70. UNGA resolution of 2 March 2022, Aggression against Ukraine, Doc. A/RES/ES-11/1.
  71. UNGA resolution of 27 March 2014, Territorial integrity of Ukraine, Doc. A/RES/68/262.
  72. UNHRC, Report of the Independent International Commission of Inquiry on Ukraine, 15 March 2023, A/HRC/52/62.
  73. Unifed State Register of Court Decisions, available at: https://reyestr.court.gov.ua/ (accessed 30 August 2024).

Similar Articles

You may also start an advanced similarity search for this article.