Abstract
This article raises the issue of the proper publication of international treaties and their presence in the Polish legal system. The authors analyze this issue based on research conducted on Polish-Russian treaties from 1944–1960. Their research has shown that, during this period, only 11% of treaties were properly published. The research – conducted on a very limited subject: only bilateral agreements between Poland and the USSR – leads to the pessimistic conclusion that in Poland it is customary practice to refrain from publishing an international agreement in the Journal of Laws and that citizens do not have at their disposal a single official or unofficial source to reconstruct Poland’s current obligations, which may indeed directly concern them. Also this finding raises important questions about the accessibility and enforceability of international treaties in the Polish legal system. At the international level, the consequences of failing to publish an act and to ensure official promulgation can be much more serious. In the absence of information about published agreements, it is not possible to sufficiently and completely determine the obligations between states nor to reconstruct the relations binding them. It is also impossible to clearly determine which international agreements are still in force between countries, which are invalid and which have expired.
References
- Act of 30 December 1950 on the publication of the Journal of Laws of the Republic of Poland and the Ofcial Journal of the Republic of Poland “Monitor Polski” [1950] JoL 58, 524.
- Agreement between the Ministry of National Defence of the Republic of Poland and the Ministry of Defence of the Russian Federation on bilateral military cooperation (signed on 7 July 1993).
- Balcerak W., Diechtiarienko W.W., Basiński E., Kostiuszko I.I., Olsanskij P.N. (eds.), Dokumenty i materiały do historii stosunków polsko-radzieckich. T. 11, styczeń 1956 – grudzień 1960 [Documents and Materials on the History of Polish–Soviet Relations. Vol. 11, January 1956 – December 1960], Książka i Wiedza, Warszawa: 1987.
- Balcerak W., Diechtiarienko W.W., Bazylow I., Kostiuszko I.I. (eds.), Dokumenty i materiały do historii stosunków polsko-radzieckich. T. 10, styczeń 1950 – grudzień 1955 [Documents and Materials on the History of Polish–Soviet Relations. Vol. 10, January 1950 – December 1955], Książka i Wiedza, Warszawa: 1982.
- Basiński E., Adalińska H., Kowalski T., Chrieniow A. (eds.), Dokumenty i materiały do historii stosunków polsko-radzieckich. T. 8, styczeń 1944 – grudzień 1945 [Documents and Materials on the History of Polish–Soviet Relations. Vol. 8, January 1944 – December 1945], Książka i Wiedza, Warszawa: 1974.
- Basiński E., Diechtiarienko W.W., Kowalski T., Chrieniow A. (eds.), Dokumenty i materiały do historii stosunków polsko-radzieckich. T. 9, styczeń 1946 – grudzień 1949 [Documents and Materials on the History of Polish–Soviet Relations. Vol. 9, January 1946 – December 1949], Książka i Wiedza, Warszawa: 1974.
- Decree of 29 September 1945 on the amendment and supplementation of the provisions on the publication of the Journal of Laws [1945] JoL 55, 305.
- Decree of the President of the Republic of Poland of 6 September 1935 on the publication of the Journal of Laws of the Republic of Poland [1935] JoL 68, 423.
- Domagalski M., Pietryga T., Żemła E., Zapomniana umowa z Rosją? [Forgotten agreement with Russia?], Rzeczpospolita, 7 May 2010, available at: https://www.rp.pl/wydarzenia/art7215251-zapomnianaumowa-z-rosja (accessed 30 August 2024).
- Frankowska M., Umowy międzynarodowe. Wprowadzenie do prawa traktatów [International agreements: Introduction to the law of treaties], SGPiS, Warszawa: 1977.
- International Covenants on Civil and Political Rights and on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights [1997] JoL 38, 169.
- Juchniewicz J., Polskie uregulowania prawne i praktyka traktatowa w latach 1945–1989 [Polish legal framework and treaty practice, 1945–1989], in: E. Borowska, J. Juchniewicz, J. Krawczyk-Grzesiowska, K.J. Marciniak (eds.), 100-lecie polskiej praktyki traktatowej [100 years of Polish treaty practice], Ministerstwo Spraw Zagranicznych, Warszawa: 2018, p. 71.
- Polish Constitutional Tribunal, judgment of 19 December 2002, K 33/02.
- Polish Supreme Court, Decision of 12 July 1961, II CZ 70/61.
- Uchwała Rady Państwa i Rady Ministrów z dnia 28 grudnia 1968 r. w sprawie zawierania i wypowiadania umów międzynarodowych [Resolution of the Council of State and the Council of Ministers of 28 December 1968 on the conclusion and termination of international agreements], 3(20) Przegląd Sejmowy 65 (1997), pp. 65–71, available at: https://tinyurl.com/bddxesbz (accessed 30 August 2024).
- Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties (signed 23 May 1969, entered into forve 27 January 1980), 1155 UNTS 331.
- Wierczyńska K., Wierczyński G., Ogłaszanie umów międzynarodowych jako warunek ich bezpośredniego stosowania – kilka uwag na marginesie polskiej praktyki [Promulgation of international agreements as the condition of their direct application – some remarks on the margin of Polish practice], 3(181) Studia Prawnicze 5 (2009),pp. 5–23.
- Wierczyński G., The Polish practice regarding the promulgation of international agreements between 1945 and 2017, 36 Polish Yearbook of International Law 257 (2017), pp. 257–266.
