Vol. 42 (2022)
Special section

The “Lessons of Nuremberg”: Their Use and Abuse in the Current Russia-Ukraine War

Anastasiia Vorobiova
Institute of Legal Studies of the Polish Academy of Sciences

Published 2023-06-30

Keywords

  • memory laws,
  • Nuremberg,
  • IMT,
  • victor’s justice

How to Cite

Vorobiova, A. (2023). The “Lessons of Nuremberg”: Their Use and Abuse in the Current Russia-Ukraine War. Polish Yearbook of International Law, 42, 55–82. https://doi.org/10.24425/PYIL.2023.147170

Abstract

The Russian aggression against Ukraine is heavily influenced by the memory of World War II (WWII), used by the Russian Federation as a consolidation tool to mobilise Russian society for the fight against a “neo-Nazi Ukraine”. Since 2014 Russia has adopted a set of legislative initiatives aiming to preserve a government-prescribed narrative about the exceptionally heroic role of the USSR in WWII and prohibiting any other interpretation under the threat of criminal and administrative sanctions. Both laws are using the decision of the International Military Tribunal (IMT) as a reference point to justify and legally substantiate such an interpretation, as the USSR was one of “victorious” nations which rendered justice against the Nazis in 1946. This article aims to show how the IMT rulings have been turned into an instrument of Russian propaganda and which lessons can be learned for the future of international tribunals, as well as examines the overall Ukrainian quest for Russian accountability.

References

  1. A New Court to Prosecute Russia’s Illegal War?, International Crisis Group, 29 March 2023, available at: https://www.crisisgroup.org/global-ukraine/new-court-prosecute-russias-illegal-war (accessed 30 April 2023).
  2. Accountability for human rights violations as a result of the aggression of the Russian Federation against Ukraine: role of the international community, including the Council of Europe, 31 January 2023, available at: https://rm.coe.int/accountability-for-human-rights-violations/1680aa086e (accessed 30 April 2023).
  3. Beckerman G., How Zelensky Gave the World a Jewish Hero, The Atlantic, 27 February 2022, available at: https://t.ly/UbVc (accessed 30 April 2023).
  4. Belavusau U., Mnemonic Constitutionalism and Rule of Law in Hungary and Russia, 1 Interdisciplinary Journal of Populism (2020), pp. 16-29.
  5. Bloxham D., From the International Military Tribunal to the Subsequent Nuremberg Proceedings: The American Confrontation with Nazi Criminality Revisited, 98 History (2013), pp. 567-591.
  6. Bogush G., Nuzov I., Russia’s Supreme Court Rewrites History of the Second World War, EJIL: Talk!, 28 October 2016, available at: https://www.ejiltalk.org/russias-supreme-court-rewrites-history-of-the-second-world-war/ (accessed 30 April 2023).
  7. Cassese A., International Criminal Law, Oxford University Press, Oxford: 2013.
  8. Cherviatsova A., On the Frontline of European Memory Wars: Memory Laws and Policy in Ukraine, 5 European Papers: A Journal on Law and Integration (2020), pp. 119-136.
  9. Coynash H., Comparing Stalin to Hitler could soon get you prosecuted in Russia, saying they both invaded Poland already has, KHPG, 7 May 2021, available at: https://khpg.org/en/1608809059 (accessed 30 April 2023).
  10. Coynash H., Russia’s Supreme Court rules that the USSR did not invade Poland in 1939, KHPG, 2 September 2016, available at: https://khpg.org/en/1472775460 (accessed 30 April 2023).
  11. Domańska M., The Religion of Victory, the Cult of Superpower. The Myth of the Great Patriotic War in Contemporary Foreign Policy of the Russian Federation, 3 Institute of National Remembrance Review (2021–2022), pp. 77-125.
  12. Fedor J., Historical Falsification as a Master Trope in the Official Discourse on History Education in Putin’s Russia, 13 Journal of Educational Media, Memory, and Society (2021), pp. 107-135.
  13. Fedor J., Lewis S., Zhurzhenko T., Introduction: War and Memory in Russia, Ukraine, and Belarus, in: J. Fedor et al. (eds.), War and Memory in Russia, Ukraine and Belarus, Palgrave Macmillan, Cham: 2017.
  14. FIDH, Russia: Crimes Against history, June 2021, para. 16, available at: https://www.fidh.org/IMG/ pdf/russie-_pad-uk-web.pdf (accessed 30 April 2023).
  15. Ford S., A Hierarchy of the Goals of International Criminal Courts, 27(1) Minnesota Journal of International Law (2018), pp. 179-244.
  16. Freid D., How Zelensky Gave the Worlda Jewish Hero, Politico, 1 March 2022, available at: https://t.ly/QMQf (accessed 30 April 2023).
  17. Freidman J., Burke Friedman I., Russia’s Invasion of Ukraine Is the Result of Its Own Failure to ‘Denazify’, Politico, 5 April 2022, available at: https://t.ly/muni (accessed 30 April 2023).
  18. Gaufman E., World War II 2.0: Digital Memory of Fascism in Russia in the Aftermath of Euromaidan in Ukraine, 10 Journal of Regional Security (2015), pp. 17-35.
  19. Gliszczyńska-Grabias A., Belavusau U., Mälksoo M., Memory Laws and Memory Wars in Poland, Russia and Ukraine, 69(1) Jahrbuch des öffentlichen Rechts der Gegenwart. Neue Folge (2021), pp. 95-116.
  20. Hafetz J., Creating the Template: Nuremberg and the Post-World War II International Prosecutions, Punishing Atrocities through a Fair Trial: International Criminal Law from Nuremberg to the Age of Global Terrorism, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge: 2018.
  21. Heller K.J., Creating a Special Tribunal for Aggression Against Ukraine Is a Bad Idea, Opinio Juris, 7 March 2022, available at: http://opiniojuris.org/2022/03/07/creating-a-special-tribunal-for-aggression-against-ukraine-is-a-bad-idea/ (accessed 30 April 2023).
  22. Heller K.J., The Nuremberg Military Tribunals and the Origins of International Criminal Law, Oxford University Press, Oxford: 2011.
  23. Hirsch F., How the Soviet Union Helped Establish the Crime of Aggressive War, Just Security, 9 March 2022, available at: https://www.justsecurity.org/80599/how-the-soviet-union-helped-establish-the-crime-of- aggressive-war/ (accessed 30 April 2023).
  24. Hirsch F., The Soviets at Nuremberg: International Law, Propaganda, and the Making of the Postwar Order, 113 The American Historical Review (2008), pp. 701-730.
  25. Hirsch F., Why Ukraine and Russia Both Look to the Nuremberg Trials, The Time, 26 May 2022, available at: https://cutt.ly/n9OOE7s (accessed 30 April 2023).
  26. Hirsch M., The Role of International Tribunals in the Development of Historical Narratives, 20(4) Journal of the History of International Law / Revue d’histoire du Droit International (2019), pp. 391-428.
  27. Investigative Committee of the Russian Federation, СК поддержал проект о запрете отождествления действий СССР и Германии во Второй мировой [The Investigative Committee supported the project on the prohibition of identification of the actions of the USSR and Germany in the Second World War], 6 May 2021, available at: https://www.pnp.ru/politics/sk-podderzhal-proekt-o-zaprete-otozhdestvleniya-deystviy-sssr-i- germanii-vo-vtoroy-mirovoy.html (accessed 30 April 2023).
  28. Jackson J., Victors Write the Rules: Hypocrisies and Legacies of the Nuremberg Trials, 8 Journal of Global Faultlines (2021), pp. 265-270.
  29. Jackson R., Opening Address for the United States, available at: http://fcit.usf.edu/holocaust/resource/ document/docjac01.htm (accessed 30 April 2023).
  30. Koposov N., Defending Stalinism by Means of Criminal Law: Russia, 1995–2014, in: U. Belavusau, A. Gliszczyńska-Grabias (eds.), Law and Memory, 1st ed, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge: 2017.
  31. Koposov N., The Only Possible Ideology: Nationalizing History in Putin’s Russia, 24 Journal of Genocide Research (2022), pp. 205-215.
  32. Koskenniemi M., Between Impunity and Show Trials, 6 Max Planck Yearbook of United Nations Law (2002), pp. 1-32.
  33. Krasov A., На Украине проведем Нюрнберг 2.0 [We’ll hold Nuremberg 2.0 in Ukraine], Parliament Union of Russia and Belarus, 11 May 2022, available at: https://cutt.ly/59OOQ Jw (accessed 30 April 2023).
  34. Kravchenko M., What should Russia do with Ukraine? [Translation of a propaganda article by a Russian publication], Medium, 4 April 2022, available at: https://tinyurl.com/5msrtcs8 (accessed 30 April 2023).
  35. Kress C., Hobe S., Nußberger A., The Ukraine War and the Crime of Aggression: How to Fill the Gaps in the International Legal System, Just Security, 23 January 2023, available at: https://tinyurl.com/2krtzsaj (accessed 30 April 2023).
  36. Laico Ch.M., Telford Taylor and the Precedent of the Nuremberg Trials, Columbia University Libraries available at: https://blogs.cul.columbia.edu/rbml/2018/01/26/telford-taylor-and-the-precedent-of-the- nuremberg-trials/ (accessed 30 April 2023).
  37. Lynch S., Ukraine at UN: We need a Nuremberg-style war crimes trial, Politico, 20 September 2022, available at: https://www.politico.eu/article/ukraine-un-nuremberg-style-war-crime-trial/ (accessed 30 April 2023).
  38. Macias A., Zelenskyy calls for a Nuremberg-style tribunal to investigate and prosecute Russian war crimes, CNBC, 5 April 2022, available at: https://tinyurl.com/2myj4j97 (accessed 30 April 2023).
  39. Mälksoo M., Memory Must be Defended: Beyond the Politics of Mnemonical Security, 6(3) Security Dialogue (2015), pp. 221-237.
  40. Matvienko V., Суд народов. Аксиома Нюрнберга [Court of Nations. Axiom of Nuremberg], 20 November 2020, available at: http://council.gov.ru/services/discussions/blogs/121555/ (accessed 30 April 2023).
  41. McDougall C., The Imperative of Prosecuting Crimes of Aggression Committed against Ukraine, Journal of Conflict and Security Law (2023), pp. 203-230.
  42. Minear R.H., Victors’ Justice: The Tokyo Trial, Princeton University Press, Princeton: 1971.
  43. Moreno Ocampo L., A Pragmatic Legal Approach to End Russia’s Aggression, Just Security, 23 February 2023, available at: https://tinyurl.com/53penupb (accessed 30 April 2023).
  44. Nuzov I., Legislating Propaganda, 20(4) Journal of International Criminal Justice 805 (2022), pp. 805-818.
  45. Nuzov I., The Role of Political Elite in Transitional Justice in Russia: From False ‘Nurembergs’ to Failed Desovietization, 20 U.C. Davis Journal of International Law & Policy 273 (2014).
  46. Ocampo L.M., Ending Selective Justice for the International Crime of Aggression, Just Security, 31 January 2023, available at: https://tinyurl.com/3dt6zth2 (accessed 30 April 2023).
  47. Overy R., BBC - History – World Wars: Making Justice at Nuremberg, 1945-1946, BBC, 17 February 2011, available at: https://www.bbc.co.uk/history/worldwars/wwtwo/war_crimes_trials_01.shtml (accessed 30 April 2023).
  48. Peskin V., Beyond Victor’s Justice? The Challenge of Prosecuting the Winners at the International Criminal Tribunals for the Former Yugoslavia and Rwanda, 4 Journal of Human Rights (2005), pp. 213-231.
  49. Pomeranz W., Review on Francine Hirsch. Soviet Judgment at Nuremberg: A New History of the International Military Tribunal after World War II (H-Diplo REVIEW ESSAY 500), available at: https:// networks.h-net.org/node/28443/discussions/11582172/h-diplo-review-essay-500-pomeranz-hirsch-soviet- judgment (accessed 30 April 2023).
  50. Prague Declaration on European Conscience and Communism, (03 June 2008), available at: https:// www.praguedeclaration.eu (accessed 30 April 2023).
  51. Priemel K.C., Historical Reasoning and Judicial Historiography in International Criminal Trials, in: K. Heller et al. (eds.), The Oxford Handbook of International Criminal Law, Oxford University Press, Oxford: 2020.
  52. Resolution 2019/2819(RSP) of 19 September 2019 on Importance of European remembrance for the future of Europe [2019].
  53. Rofe J., В РФ введен штраф за сравнение СССР и нацистской Германии [Russia introduced a fine for comparing the USSR and Nazi Germany], Deutsche Welle, 16 April 2022, available at: https://www. dw.com/ru/putin-podpisal-zakon-o-shtrafah-za-sravnenie-sssr-s-nacistskoj-germaniej/a-61494911 (accessed 30 April 2023).
  54. Rossoliński-Liebe G., Willem B., Putin’s Abuse of History: Ukrainian “Nazis”, “Genocide”, and a Fake Threat Scenario, 35 The Journal of Slavic Military Studies (2022).
  55. Roth A., Kremlin Mulls Nuremberg-Style Trials Based on Second World War Tribunals, The Guardian, 28 May 2022.
  56. Santry C., The Nuremberg Trial: A Beautiful Idea Murdered by Ugly Facts?, E-International Relations, 19 August 2013, available at: https://www.e-ir.info/2013/08/19/the-nuremberg-trial-a-beautiful-idea-murdered-by-ugly-facts/ (accessed 30 April 2023).
  57. Schabas W. (ed.), Unimaginable Atrocities: Justice, Politics, and Rights at the War Crimes Tribunals, Oxford University Press, Oxford: 2012.
  58. Schabas W., Victor’s Justice: Selecting “Situations” at the International Criminal Court, 43 John Marshall Law Review (2010).
  59. Seregin A.V., Слово ученых [The Word of Scientists], available at: https://histrf.ru/uploads/media/ default/0001/26/d9e3aaa29073a6dca40b70eb29cf186eacac2395.pdf (accessed 30 April 2023).
  60. Talley W., Debunking ‘ denazification’, Commission on Security and Cooperation in Europe, 21 April 2022, available at: https://t.ly/MPhT (accessed 30 April 2023).
  61. The Case of Vladimir Luzgin, Global Freedom of Expression, available at: https://globalfreedomofexpression.columbia.edu/cases/case-vladimir-luzgin/ (accessed 30 April 2023).
  62. US Department of State, To Vilify Ukraine, The Kremlin Resorts to Antisemitism, 11 July 2022, available at: https://t.ly/ScLL (accessed 30 April 2023).
  63. Van Shaack B., Setting the Record Straight on the Soviets at Nuremberg, War on the Rocks, 17 June 2020, available at: http://warontherocks.com/2020/06/setting-the-record-straight-on-the-soviets-at-nuremberg/ (accessed 30 April 2023).
  64. Walke A., Old and new fault lines in the wake of Russia’s assault on Ukraine, Georgie W. Lewis University, 15 March 2022, available at: https://history.wustl.edu/news/old-and-new-fault-lines-wake-russia’s-assault-ukraine (accessed 30 April 2023).
  65. Александр Звягинцев, На Украине забыли уроки Нюрнбергского процесса [Ukraine has forgotten Nuremberg lessons], Edinaya Rossiya, 30 March 2022, available at: https://er.ru/activity/news/aleksandr- zvyagincev-na-ukraine-zabyli-uroki-nyurnbergskogo-processa (accessed 30 April 2023).
  66. В «Артеке» состоялась реконструкция Нюрнбергского процесса [Reconstruction of the Nuremberg trials took place in Artek], available at: https://artek.org/press-centr/news/v-arteke-proshla- rekonstrukciya-nyurnbergskogo-processa/ (accessed 30 April 2023).
  67. В Артеке проведут реконструкцию Нюрнбергского процесса [Reconstruction of the Nuremberg trials will be held in Artek], Radio Azzatyk, 26 November 2022, available at: https://rus.azattyk. org/a/28877488.html (accessed 30 April 2023).
  68. Интерпретацию итогов Нюрнберга предложили считать преступлением [The interpretation of the results of Nuremberg was proposed to be considered a crime], Pobeda.rf, 21 October 2022, available at: https://pobedarf.ru/2022/10/21/interpretacziyu-itogov-nyurnberga-predlozhili-schitat-prestupleniem/ (accessed 30 April 2023).
  69. Историческая правда стала оружием [Historical truth has become a weapon], Pobeda.rf, 19 April 2022, available at: https://pobedarf.ru/2022/04/19/istoricheskaya-pravda-stala-oruzhiem/ (accessed 30 April 2023).
  70. МИД напомнил Европе о Нюрнбергском трибунале [The Foreign Ministry reminded Europe of the Nuremberg Tribunal], Pobeda.rf, 20 November 2020), available at: https://cutt.ly/G9OOYII (accessed 30 April 2023).
  71. Нюрнбергский процесс: история и современность [Nuremberg trials: history and modernity], Krymskie Izvestiya, 18 November 2022, available at: https://new.crimiz.ru/rubriki/101-istoriya/19865- nyurnbergskij-protsess-istoriya-i-sovremennost (accessed 30 April 2023).
  72. Нюрнбергский процесс: школьники сложили пазл исторического события [Nuremberg trials: schoolchildren put together a puzzle of a historical event], Ogni Agideli, 23 November 2022, available at: https://ogni-agideli.ru/news/novosti/2022-11-23/nyurnbergskiy-protsess-shkolniki-slozhili-pazl- istoricheskogo-sobytiya-3042284 (accessed 30 April 2023).
  73. Ответ официального представителя МИД России М.В.Захаровой на вопрос агентства «РИА Новости» в связи с принятием Европарламентом резолюции «О важности сохранения исторической памяти для будущего Европы» [Response of MFA Spokesperson Maria Zakharova to the RIA Novosti agency on the adoption of the European Parliament resolution “On the Importance of Preserving Historical Memory for the Future of Europe”], available at: https://tinyurl.com/2p8vmuy2 (accessed 30 April 2023).
  74. Портал Возмездие защитит историческую память [Portal Retribution will protect historical memory], Pobeda.rf, 19 October 2022, available at: https://pobedarf.ru/2022/10/19/portal-vozmezdie- zashhitit-istoricheskuyu-pamyat/ (accessed 30 April 2023).
  75. Процесс: История Международного Военного Трибунала в Нюрнберге глазами журналистов [The process: history of the IMT as told by the journalists], (TASS), available at: https://spec.tass.ru/ nurnbergskiy-process/ (accessed 30 April 2023).
  76. Разговоры о важном, День памяти о геноциде советского народа нацистами и их пособниками [Conversations about the important, Day of Remembrance of the genocide of the Soviet people by the Nazis and their accomplices], available at: https://razgovor.edsoo.ru/video/2486/ (accessed 30 April 2023).
  77. Семинар-симпозиум«Нюрнбергскийтрибунал: историческое значениеиурокидлясовременности» [Seminar-symposium “The Nuremberg Tribunal: Historical Significance and Lessons for the Present”], Far East Federal University, 18 November 2022), available at: https://www.dvfu.ru/schools/school_of_ education/news/seminar-simpozium-nyurnbergsky-tribunal-202211/ (accessed 30 April 2023).
  78. УК РФ Статья 354.1. Реабилитация нацизма [Criminal Code Article 354.1. Rehabilitation of Nazism] (Consultant Plus), available at: https://www.consultant.ru/document/cons_doc_LAW_10699/ be763c1b6a1402144cabfe17a0e2d602d4bb7598/ (accessed 30 April 2023).
  79. Україна підтримала ініціативу “Нюрнберг-2” щодо притягнення Росії та її лідерів до відповідальності [Ukraine supported the “Nuremberg-2” initiative to bring Russia and its leaders to justice], Pryamyy, 6 May 2022, available at: https://tinyurl.com/3y4exbu3 (accessed 30 April 2023).
  80. Федеральный закон от 16.04.2022 № 103-ФЗ «О внесении изменений в Кодекс Российской Федерации об административных правонарушениях» [Federal Law No. 103-FZ as of 16 April 2022 “On Amendments to the Code of Administrative Offenses of the Russian Federation:], available at: http://publication.pravo.gov. ru/Document/View/0001202204160015?index=3&rangeSize=1 (accessed 30 April 2023).
  81. Форум «Нюрнбергский процесс: история и современность» состоялся в «Артеке» [Forum “Nuremberg trials: history and modernity” was held in “Artek”], Russian Bar Association, 5 November 2017, available at: https://alrf.ru/news/forum-nyurnbergskiy-protsess-istoriya-i-sovremennost-sostoyalsya-v-arteke/ (accessed 30 April 2023).
  82. «Юные правоведы» провели реконструкцию Нюрнбергского процесса в «Артеке» [“Young jurists” conducted re-enactment of the Nuremberg trials in “Artek”], (Artek, 25 November 2022) available at: https://artek.org/press-centr/news/yunye-pravovedy-proveli-rekonstrukciyu-nyurnbergskogo-processa- v-arteke/ (accessed 30 April 2023).