Germany et al. v. Philipp et al.: Human Rights Exception to State Immunity Rejected

Zgłoś artykuł

PDF (English)

Słowa kluczowe

domestic taking
FSIA
jurisdictional immunities
Philipp et al.
state immunity

Jak cytować

Gubrynowicz, A. (2021). Germany et al. v. Philipp et al.: Human Rights Exception to State Immunity Rejected. Polish Yearbook of International Law, 40, 243–253. https://doi.org/10.24425/pyil.2021.138439

Abstrakt

This article discusses some recent developments in the US jurisprudence concerning state immunity. Some lower courts’ decisions handed down earlier suggested a more decisive departure from the rigid interpretation of the Foreign Sovereign Immunity Act (FSIA). If the US Supreme Court had accepted this new jurisprudential trend, it would possibly allow for carving out a partial acceptance of a human rights exception. However, the Supreme Court decided otherwise. In the recently handed-down decision in Germany et al. v. Philipp et al., the Justices rejected any innovations, unequivocally maintained the strict interpretation of FSIA Åò1603(a)(3), and by their direct reference to the International Court of Justice strengthened the existing status quo in international law as well. This note analyzes this decision’s possible consequences at the domestic and international levels. In conclusion, it seeks to place Germany vs. Philipp in a broader context. It suggests that it possibly reflects more general tendencies in the contemporary US jurisprudence, which can impact both the US domestic legal order and international law.

https://doi.org/10.24425/pyil.2021.138439
PDF (English)

Bibliografia

Case Abelesz et al. v. Nemzeti Bank, 692 F.3d 661 (7th Cir. 2012), 22 August 2012.

Case Claude Cassirer v. the Kingdom of Spain et al., 461 F. Supp. 2D 1157, 30 August 2006.

Case Davoyan v. Republic Turkey, 116 F. Supp. 3d 1084 (C.D. Cal. 2013), 26 March 2013.

Case Germany et al. v. Philipp et al. 592 US, 07 December 2020.

Case Philipp v. Federal Republic of Germany, 248 F. Supp. 3d 59 (D.D.C. 2017), 31 March 2017.

Case Philipp v. Federal Republic of Germany, 894 F.3d 406 (D.C. Cir. 2018), 10 July 2018.

Case Republic of Austria v. Altmann, 41 US 677, 07 June 2004.

Case Simon v. the Republic of Hungary 812 F.3d 127 (D.C. Cir. 2016), 29 January 2016.

Case Simon v. the Republic of Hungary, No. 17-7146 (D. C. Cir. 2018), 20 April 2018.

Cases The Schooner Exchange v. McFaddon, 11 US (7 Cranch) 116 (1812). 7 US C 28, §§ 1330, 1332, 1391(f), 1441(d), and 1602–1615.

Djoukeng F.J., Genocidal Takings and the F.S.I.A.: Jurisdictional Limitations, „Georgetown Law Journal” 2018, nr 106, s. 1883-1913, https://www.law.georgetown.edu/georgetown-law-journal/wp-content/uploads/sites/26/2018/10/Genocidal-Takings-and-the-FSIA.pdf.

Dodge W.S., The Meaning of the Supreme Court’s Ruling in Germany v. Philipp, Just Security (8 February 2021), https://bit.ly/3gPnN4o.

Dodge, William S., Brief of Professor William S. Dodge as Amicus Curiae in Support of Plaintiffs-Appellants, Simon v. Republic of Hungary (February 5, 2018), https://ssrn.com/abstract=3118607, http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.3118607.

Fox H., Webb P., The Law of State Immunity (3rd ed.), Oxford University Press, Oxford 2013.

International Court of Justice, Armed Activities on the Territory of the Congo (New Application: 2002) (Democratic Republic of the Congo v. Rwanda), Jurisdiction and Admissibility, Judgment (2006) ICJ Rep 64, 3 February 2006.

Judgment of Corte Costituzionale, No. 238/2014. For the English translation, 22 October 2014, https://bit.ly/3gNqraK.

Judgment of International Court of Justice, Jurisdictional Immunities of the State (Germany v. Italy: Greece intervening), 3 February 2012.

Kiobel v. Royal Dutch Petroleum Co., 569 US 108, 115, 17 April 2013.

Krieger H., Sentenza 238/14: A Good Case for Law-Reform?, [w:] A. von Bogdandy, A. Peters (red.) Beiträge zum ausländischen öffentlichen Recht und Völkerrecht, Springer, Berlin/Heidelberg 2021.

Nestlé U.S.A., Inc., Petitioner v. John Doe I, et al. (17-55435), Docket number: 19-416 and 19-453, 27 September 2019.

Pavoni R., An American anomaly? On the I.C.J.’s selective reading of United States practice in jurisdictional immunities of states, „Italian Yearbook of International Law” 2011, nr 21, s. 143-159.

Peters A., Volpe V., Reconciling State Immunity with Remedies for War Victims in a Legal Pluriverse, [w:] V. Volpe, A. Peters, S. Battini (red.), Remedies against Immunity? Reconciling International and Domestic Law after the Italian Constitutional Court’s Sentenza 238/2014, Springer, Berlin 2021.

Restatement of the Law Fourth, Restatement of the Law, The Foreign Relations Law of The United States, Selected Topics in Treaties, Jurisdiction, and Sovereign Immunity, The American Law Institute Publishers, Saint Paul 2018.

Supreme Court decision in the Simon case (3 February 2021), 592 US, 3 February 2021, https://bit.ly/3d9bGNd.

Verlinden B.V. v. Central Bank of Nigeria, 461 US 480, 11 January 1983.