Reaffirmation of the Direct Horizontal Effect of the General Principle of Non-Discrimination in EU Law: Comment on the Case C-193/17 Cresco Investigation Gmbh v. Markus Achatzi

Zgłoś artykuł

PDF (English)

Słowa kluczowe

Cresco Investigation
direct horizontal effect
discrimination based on religion
EU Charter of Fundamental Rights
general principle of non-discrimination in EU Law

Jak cytować

Maliszewska-Nienartowicz, J. (2021). Reaffirmation of the Direct Horizontal Effect of the General Principle of Non-Discrimination in EU Law: Comment on the Case C-193/17 Cresco Investigation Gmbh v. Markus Achatzi. Polish Yearbook of International Law, 40, 229–241. https://doi.org/10.24425/pyil.2021.138438

Abstrakt

The relevant ruling concerns discrimination based on religion, in particular the question of the incompatibility of national legislation with EU Directive 2000/78. Following a short presentation of the factual background, the opinion of the Advocate General, and the judgment of the Court, the article offers comments on questions raised in the judgment, including the direct horizontal effect of the general principle of non-discrimination. In its previous case law the Court confirmed that the principle has “the horizontal exclusion effect.” However, in Cresco Investigation the question was whether it can be the source of rights for individuals. The ECJ adopted a firm approach, ruling that the general principle of non-discrimination as enshrined in Art. 21(1) of the Charter is sufficient in itself to confer rights on individuals which can be invoked in disputes with other private parties. This means that the Court recognized “the horizontal substitution effect” of the general principle of non-discrimination, which is connected with both setting aside any discriminatory provision of national law and applying to members of the disadvantaged group the same arrangements as those enjoyed by persons in the privileged category. The possible consequences of this approach are discussed in the article.

https://doi.org/10.24425/pyil.2021.138438
PDF (English)

Bibliografia

A.G. Mazák’s opinion in case C-411/05 Félix Palacios de la Villa v. Cortefiel Servicios SA., EU:C:2007:106, 15 February 2007.

A.G. Sharpston’s opinion in case C-227/04 P, Maria-Luise Lindorfer v Council of the European Union, EU:C:2006:748, 20 November 2006.

A.G. Sharpston’s opinion in case C-427/06 Birgit Bartsch v. Bosch und Siemens Hausgeräte (BSH) Altersfürsorge GmbH, EU:C:2008:297, 22 May 2008.

Case C-144/04 Werner Mangold v. Rüdiger Helm, EU:C:2005:709, 22 November 2005.

Case C-157/15 Samira Achbita and Centrum voor gelijkheid van kansen en voor racismebestrijding v. G4S Secure Solutions NV, EU:C:2017:203, 14 March 2017.

Case C-176/12 Association de médiation sociale v. Union locale des syndicats CGT and Others, EU:C:2014:2, 15 January 2014.

Case C-188/15 Asma Bougnaoui and Association de défense des droits de l’homme (ADDH) v. Micropole SA, EU:C:2017:204, 14 March 2017.

Case C-281/98 Roman Angonese v. Cassa di Risparmio di Bolzano SpA., EU:C:2000:296, 06 June 2000.

Case C-414/16 Vera Egenberger v. Evangelisches Werk für Diakonie und Entwicklung e.V., EU:C: 2018:257, 17 April 2018.

Case C-43/75 Gabrielle Defrenne v. Société anonyme belge de navigation aérienne Sabena, EU:C: 1976:56, 8 April 1976.

Case C-441/14 Dansk Industri (DI), acting on behalf of Ajos A/S v. Estate of Karsten Eigil Rasmussen, EU:C:2016:278, 19 April 2016.

Case C-447/09 Reinhard Prigge and Others v. Deutsche Lufthansa AG, EU:C:2011:573, 13 September 2011.

Case C-555/07 Seda Kücükdeveci v. Swedex GmbH & Co. KG., EU:C:2010:21, 10 January 2010.

Case C-68/17 IR v. JQ, EU:C:2018:696, 11 September 2018.

Ciacchi A.C., The Direct Horizontal Effect of EU Fundamental Rights. ECJ 17 April 2018, Case C-414/16, Vera Egenberger v Evangelisches Werk für Diakonie und Entwicklung e.V. and ECJ 11 September 2018, Case C-68/17, IR v JQ, „European Constitutional Law Review” 2019, nr 15, s. 294-305, http://robertgrzeszczak.bio.wpia.uw.edu.pl/files/2012/12/direct_horizontal_effect_of_eu_fundamental_rights.pdf.

Craig P., de Búrca G., EU Law: Text, Cases and Materials (6th ed.), Oxford University Press, Oxford 2015.

de Mol M., The Novel Approach of the CJEU on the Horizontal Direct Effect of the EU Principle of Non-Discrimination: (Unbridled) Expansionism of EU Law?, „Maastricht Journal of European and Comparative Law” 2011, nr 18, s. 109-135.

Fontanelli F., Some Reflections on the General Principles of EU and on Solidarity in the Aftermath of Mangold and Kücükdevec, „European Public Law” 2011, nr 17, s. 225-240.

Frantziou E., (Most of) the Charter of Fundamental Rights is horizontally applicable: ECJ 6 November 2018, joined cases C-569/16 and C-570/16, Bauer et al., „European Constitutional Law Review” 2019, nr 15, s. 306-323.

Frantziou E., The Horizontal Effect of Fundamental Rights in the European Union: A Constitutional Analysis, Oxford University Press, Oxford 2019.

Frantziou E., The Horizontal Effect of the Charter of Fundamental Rights of the European Union: Rediscovering the Reasons for Horizontality, „European Law Journal” 2015, nr 21, s. 657-679.

Joined Cases C-231/06 to C-233/06 National Pensions Office v Emilienne Jonkman, Hélène Vercheval and Noëlle Permesaen v. National Pensions Office, EU:C:2007:373, 21 June 2007.

Joined cases C-569/16 and C-570/16 Stadt Wuppertal v. Maria Elisabeth Bauer and Volker Willmeroth v. Martina Broßonn, EU:C:2018:871, 6 November 2018.

Leczykiewcz D., Effectiveness of EU Law before National Courts: Direct Effect, Effective Judicial Protection and State Liability, [w:] D. Chalmers, A. Arnull (red.), The Oxford Handbook of European Union Law, Oxford University Press, Oxford 2015.

Official Journal of the European Communities, OJ L 303, 2000.

Opinion of A.G. Trstenjak in case C-282/10 Maribel Dominguez v. Centre informatique du Centre Ouest Atlantique and Préfet de la région Centre, EU:C:2011:559, 8 September 2011.

Papadopoulos T., Criticizing the Horizontal Direct Effect of the EU General Principle of Equality, „European Human Rights Law Review” 2011, nr 11, s. 438-449.

Schiek D., Constitutional Principles and Horizontal Effect: Kücükdeveci Revisited, „European Labour Law Journal” 2010, nr 1, s. 368-379.

Sever S., Horizontal Effect and the Charter, „Croatian Yearbook of European Law” 2014, nr 10, s. 39-65.

Wyatt D., Horizontal Effect of Fundamental Freedoms and the Right to Equality After Viking and Mangold, and the Implications for Community Competence, „Croatian Yearbook of European Law and Policy” 2008 nr 4, s. 1- 48.

Zaccaroni G., Is the horizontal application of general principles ultra vires? Dialogue and conflict between supreme European courts in Dansk Industri, „Federalismi.it” 2010, nr 9, s. 2-17, https://orbilu.uni.lu/bitstream/10993/35547/1/Zaccaroni_Federalismi.pdf.