Vol. 42 (2022)
General Articles

Age Assessment: Polish Practice and International Standards

Joanna Markiewicz-Stanny
University of Zielona Góra

Published 2023-06-30

Keywords

  • age assessment,
  • unaccompanied children,
  • international protection

How to Cite

Markiewicz-Stanny, J. (2023). Age Assessment: Polish Practice and International Standards. Polish Yearbook of International Law, 42, 185–202. https://doi.org/10.24425/PYIL.2023.147175

Abstract

This article addresses the legal aspects of assessing the age of foreign minors. It is a juxtaposition of the development of international legal standards in this area with the law and practice of the Polish authorities. The basic thesis of this analysis is the statement that Polish law in its current form requires fundamental change with respect to at least three elements. First, it is necessary to extend the methods of age assessment to also include non-medical methods. Secondly, the law should clearly define the legal form in which the age of a foreigner is determined and, at the same time, impose an obligation to provide a foreigner with the results of the assessment. Thirdly, a person concerned should have a direct opportunity to appeal.

References

  1. Abdullahi Elmi and Aweys Abubakar v. Malta (App. Nos. 25794/13 and 28151/13), 22 November 2016.
  2. Alshramani, K., Messina, F., Offiah, A., Is the Greulich and Pyle atlas applicable to all ethnicities? A systematic review and meta-analysis, 29(6) European Radiology (2019), pp. 2910-2923.
  3. Art. 222 - R.11 Code de l’action sociale et des familles [Family and Social Code], text available at: https://www.legifrance.gouv.fr/codes/texte_lc/LEGITEXT000006074069/
  4. Art. 87 of the Constitution of Republic of Poland, Journal of Laws 1997, No. 78, item 483, as amended.
  5. Cemlyn, S.J., Nye, M., Asylum seeker young people: Social work value conflict in negotiating age assessment in the UK, 55(5) International Social Work (2012), pp. 675-688.
  6. CoE Parliamentary Assembly Resolution 2195 (2017), para. 6.3.
  7. CoE Parliamentary Assembly, Resolution 2195 (2017), para. 6.4.
  8. Convention on the Rights of the Child (signed on 20 November 1989, entered into force 2 September 1990), 1577 UNTS 3, Arts. 3, 8 and 12.
  9. Council Directive 2001/55/EC of 20 July 2001 on minimum standards for giving temporary protection in the event of a mass influx of displaced persons and on measures promoting a balance of efforts between Member States in receiving such persons and bearing the consequences thereof [2001] OJ L 212.
  10. Council Implementing Decision (EU) 2022/382 of 4 March 2022 establishing the existence of a mass influx of displaced persons from Ukraine within the meaning of Article 5 of Directive 2001/55/EC, and having the effect of introducing temporary protection [2022] OJ L 71.
  11. Council of Europe Convention on the Protection of Children against Sexual Exploitation and Sexual Abuse, 25 October 2007 (Lanzarote Convention).
  12. CtRC, M.T. v. Spain, CRC/C/82/D/17/2017, 18 September 2019, para.
  13. CtRC, R.Y.S. v. Spain, CRC/C/86/D/76/2019, 4 February 2021, para. 8.8.
  14. CtRC, S.E.M.A v. France, CRC/C/92/D/130/2020, 25 January 2023, para. 8.5.
  15. Directive 2013/32/EU of 26 June 2013 on common procedures for granting and withdrawing international protection (recast) [2013] OJ EU L 180/60.
  16. ECtHR (GC), Darboe and Camara v. Italy (App. No. 5797/17), 21 July 2022.
  17. ECtHR, Ahmade v. Greece (App. No. 50520/09), 25 September 2012, paras. 77 and 78.
  18. ECtHR, Al - Agha v. Romania (App. No. 40933/02), 12 January 2010, para. 89.
  19. ECtHR, Nolan and K. v. Russia (App. No. 2512/04), 12 February 2009, paras. 98-99.
  20. European Committee on Social Rights, European Committee for Home-Based Priority Action for the Child and the Family (EUROCEF) v. France, Complaint No. 114/2015, Decision of 15 June 2018, para. 113.
  21. Klaus, W. (ed.), Beyond the Law. Legal assessment of the Polish state’s activities in response to the humanitarian crisis on the Polish-Belarusian border, ILS PAS, Warsaw: 2022.
  22. Loder, R.T. et al., Applicability of the Greulich and Pyle skeletal age standards to black and white children of today, 147(12) American Journal of Diseases of Children (1993), pp. 1329-1333.
  23. M.A.B. v. Spain, CRC/C/83/D/24/2017, 7 February 2020, para. 10.6.
  24. Machińska, H., Kusy, M., Kazimirski, P. (eds.), Sytuacja cudzoziemców w ośrodkach strzeżonych w dobie kryzysu na granicy Polski i Białorusi Raport z wizytacji Krajowego Mechanizmu Prewencji Tortur [Condition of foreigners in guarded centers during the period of crisis on the Polish-Belarusian border. Report on the visit of the National Mechanism for the Prevention of Torture], RPO, Warszawa: 2022, available at: https://tinyurl.com/42vwvp38 (accessed 30 April 2023).
  25. Mahamed Jama v. Malta (App. No. 10290/13), 26 November 2015.
  26. Maneggia, A., The Principle of the Best Interests of the Child in the Italian System of Protection of Unaccompanied Migrant Children, in: J. Markiewicz-Stanny, T. Milej, A. Wedeł-Domaradzka (eds.), Children in Migration: Status and Identity, Nomos Verlag, Baden-Baden: 2022.
  27. Mansourvar F.M. et al., The applicability of the Greulich and Pyle atlas to assess skeletal age for four ethnic groups, 22 Journal of Forensic and Legal Medicine (2014), pp. 26-29.
  28. Markiewicz-Stanny, J., Age assessment procedures and the protection of children’s rights: an analysis of international standards, in: M. Półtorak, I. Topa (eds.), Women Children and (Other) Vulnerable Groups. Standards of Protection and Challenges for International Law, Peter Lang, Berlin: 2021.
  29. Mishori, R., Case Report The Use of Age Assessment in the Context of Child Migration: Imprecise, Inaccurate, Inconclusive and Endangers Children’s Rights, 6 Children 85 (2019), pp. 85-89.
  30. Nationality and Borders Act 2022, 2022 Chapter 36, part 4, section 50-52, text available https:// www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/2022/36/enacted
  31. Regulation (EC) No 767/2008 of 9 July 2008 concerning the Visa Information System (VIS) and the exchange of data between Member States on short-stay visas (VIS Regulation) [2008] OJ L 218.
  32. Resolution 1810 (2011), para. 5.10.
  33. Resolution 2195(2017) on child-friendly age assessment for unaccompanied migrant children, 24 November 2017, para. 2.
  34. Sauer, P., Nicholson, A., Neubauer, D., Age determination in asylum seekers: physicians should not be implicated, 175 European Journal of Pediatrics (2016), 299-303.
  35. Smith, T., Brownlee, L., Age assessment practices: A literature review & annotated bibliography, Discussion Paper, UNICEF: 2011.
  36. Sørsveen, A.T., Ursin, M., Constructions of ‘the ageless’ asylum seekers: An analysis of how age is understood among professionals working within the Norwegian immigration authorities, 35 Children and Society (2021), pp. 198-212.
  37. Tacik, P., Law, Life, Impossibility: Theorising ‘Law Application’ in Detention Centres for Foreigners, 4(186) Studia Migracyjne. Przegląd Polonijny (2022), pp. 35-52.
  38. Tymińska, A., Dzieci z pieczy zastępczej oraz małoletni bez opieki z Ukrainy: ocena ex-post regulacji i praktyki stosowania specustawy ukraińskiej [Children from foster care and unaccompanied minors from Ukraine: ex-post evaluation of the regulations and practice of applying the Ukrainian Special Act], HFPCz, Warszawa: 2022, available at: https://tinyurl.com/yc87zhxz (accessed 30 April 2023).
  39. Ustawa o cudzoziemcach [Aliens Act], Journal of Laws 2013, item 1650, consolidated text Journal of Laws 2021.
  40. Ustawa o pomocy obywatelom Ukrainy w związku z konfliktem zbrojnym na terytorium tego państwa [The Act on assistance to Ukrainian citizens in connection with armed conflict on the territory of that state], Journal of Laws 2022.
  41. Ustawa o udzielaniu cudzoziemcom ochrony na terytorium Rzeczypospolitej Polskiej [Act on granting protection to aliens within the territory of the Republic of Poland], Journal of Laws 2003, No. 128, item 1176, consolidated text Journal of Laws 2022, items 1264, 1383 as amended.
  42. Wenke, D., Age assessment: Council of Europe member states’ policies, procedures and practices respectful of children’s rights in the context of migration, CoE, Strasbourg: 2017.