Make a Submission
Vol. 43 (2023)
General Articles

State Aid for Green Technologies in the European Union: Limitations and Risks

PDF
  • Jakub Kociubiński
Jakub Kociubiński
Administration and Economics, University of Wrocław, Poland

Published 2024-06-25

Keywords

  • carbon leakage,
  • environmental aid,
  • EU law,
  • GBER,
  • State aid

How to Cite

State Aid for Green Technologies in the European Union: Limitations and Risks. (2024). Polish Yearbook of International Law, 43, 123–147. https://doi.org/10.24425/pyil.2024.152296

Abstract

This article analyzes the recently adopted European Union State aid rules designed to facilitate the implementation of “green” technologies. This initiative is in line with European objectives to combat climate change and transition to an emission-free economy. By contextualizing State aid rules within the broader regulatory policy landscape, the author aims to assess the inherent limitations of these tools. Based on this evaluation, the article attempts to determine if and to what extent EU State aid law can be successfully utilized to promote environmental objectives.
The analysis begins with an overview of the State aid toolbox and its role in regulatory policies, situated on a spectrum between incentive-based and obligation-based approaches. Subsequently, it delves into the evaluation of potential consequences, encompassing risks such as the deepening disparities between wealthier and poorer Member States, inadequate safeguards against offshoring in pursuit of lenient environmental norms, and the peril of fostering subsidy dependence.

PDF

References

  1. Agrell P., Incentive Regulation of Networks: Concepts, Defnitions and Models, 54(1) Reflets et perspectives de la vie économique 103 (2015), pp. 103–132.
  2. Almeida Neves S., Cardoso Marques A., Patrício M., Determinants of CO2 Emissions in European Union Countries: Does Environmental Regulation Reduce Environmental Pollution?, 68 Economic Analysis and Policy 114 (2020), pp. 114–125.
  3. Authorisation for State aid pursuant to Articles 107 and 108 of the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union – Cases where the Commission raises no objections – SA.110511 [2024] OJ C 1361.
  4. Authorisation for State aid pursuant to Articles 107 and 108 of the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union – Cases where the Commission raises no objections – SA.108953 [2023] OJ C 258.
  5. Authorisation for State aid pursuant to Articles 107 and 108 of the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union – Cases where the Commission raises no objections [2021] OJ C 317/1.
  6. Authorisation for State aid pursuant to Articles 107 and 108 of the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union [2014] OJ C 280/1.
  7. Authorisation for State aid pursuant to Articles 107 and 108 of the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union [2016] OJ C 258/1.
  8. Authorisation for State aid pursuant to Articles 107 and 108 of the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union [2017] OJ C 20/1.
  9. Authorisation for State aid pursuant to Articles 107 and 108 of the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union – Cases where the Commission raises no objections – SA.109500 [2024] OJ C 729/1.
  10. Bacon K. (ed.), European Union Law of State Aid, Oxford University Press, Oxford: 2017.
  11. Baumgärtner S., Quaas M.F., Ecological-Economic Viability as a Criterion of Strong Sustainability Under Uncertainty, 68(7) Ecological Economics 2008 (2009), pp. 2008–2020.
  12. Bouchagiar A., The Binding Effects of Guidelines on the Compatibility of State Aid: How Hard is the Commission’s Soft Law?, 8(3) Journal of European Competition Law & Practice 157 (2017), pp. 157–166.
  13. Brulle R.J., Advocating Inaction: A Historical Analysis of the Global Climate Coalition, 32(2) Environmental Politics 185 (2023), pp. 185–206.
  14. Capik P., Dej M. (eds.), Relocation of Economic Activity: Contemporary Theory and Practice in Local, Regional and Global Perspectives, Springer, Cham: 2019.
  15. Carbon leakage, European Commission, available at: https://climate.ec.europa.eu/eu-action/eu-emissions-trading-system-eu-ets/free-allocation/carbonleakage_en (accessed 30 August 2024).
  16. Case C-390/06 Nuova Agricast Srl v. Ministero delle Attività Produttive, EU:C:2008:224.
  17. Case C-431/14 P Greece v. Commission, EU:C:2016:145.
  18. Case C-493/14 Dilly’s Wellnesshotel GmbH v. Finanzamt Linz, EU:C:2016:577.
  19. Case C-526/14 Tadej Kotnik and Others v. Državni zbor Republike Slovenije, EU:C:2016:570.
  20. Case C-594/18 P Austria v. Commission, EU:C:2020:742.
  21. Case C-850/19 P FVE Holýšov I s.r.o. and Others v. European Commission, EU:C:2021:740.
  22. Case C-86/89 Italian Republic v. Commission of the European Communities, EU:C:1990:373.
  23. Case T-14/96 Bretagne Angleterre Irlande (BAI) v. Commission of the European Communities, EU:T:1999:12.
  24. Case T-162/06 Kronoply GmbH & Co. KG v. Commission of the European Communities, EU:T:2009:2.
  25. Case T-176/01 Ferriere Nord SpA v. European Commission, EU:T:2004:336.
  26. Case T-348/04 Société internationale de diffusion et d’ édition SA (SIDE) v. Commission of the European Communities, EU:T:2008:109.
  27. Case T-55/99 Confederación Española de Transporte de Mercancías (CETM) v. Commission of the European Communities, EU:T:2000:223.
  28. Case T-57/11 Castelnou Energía v. Commission, EU:T:2014:1021.
  29. Case T-58/13 Club Hotel Loutraki AE and Others v. European Commission, EU:T:2015:1.
  30. Case T-671/14 Bayerische Motoren Werke AG v. European Commission, EU:T:2017:599.
  31. Coase R.H., The Problem of Social Cost, 3 Journal of Law and Economics 1 (1960), pp. 1–44.
  32. Cohen S., EPA: A Qualifed Success, in: S. Kamieniecki, R. O’Brien, M. Clarke (eds.), Controversies in Environmental Policy, State University of New York Press, Albany: 1986, pp. 174–195.
  33. Comission Decision of 23 September 2009, No. 2010/54, on the aid which Poland is planning to implement for Dell Products (Poland) Sp. z o.o. C 46/08 [2010] OJ L 132/93.
  34. Commission consults Member States on a proposal for a partial adjustment of the phase-out schedule of the State aid Temporary Crisis and Transition Framework in view of the upcoming winter heating period, European Commission, 6 November 2023, available at: https://ec.europa.eu/commission/presscorner/detail/en/ip_23_5525 (accessed 30 August 2024).
  35. Commission Decision of 1 October 2014, No. 2015/1072, on the measures implemented by Germany in favour of Propapier PM2 GmbH – State aid SA.23827 (2013/C) [2015] OJ L 179/54.
  36. Commission Decision of 24 January 2007, No. 2007/374, on State aid C 52/2005 implemented by the Italian Republic for the subsidised purchase of digital decoders [2007] OJ L 147/1.
  37. Commission Decision of 26 July 2022, No. 2023/1683, on the measure SA.26494 2012/C (ex 2012/NN) implemented by France in favour of the operator of La Rochelle airport and certain airlines operating at that airport [2023] OJ L 217/5.
  38. Commission Decision of 3 August 2011, No. 2012/466, on the aid SA. 26980 (C 34/09) which Portugal is planning to grant to Petrogal [2012] OJ L 220/1.
  39. Commission Decision of 6 July 2010, No. 2011/4, on State aid C 34/08 which Germany is planning to implement in favour of Deutsche Solar AG [2011] OJ L 7/40.
  40. Commission Decision of 9 November 2005, No. 2006/513, on the State Aid which the Federal Republic of Germany has implemented for the introduction of digital terrestrial television (DVB-T) in Berlin-Brandenburg [2007] OJ L 200/14.
  41. Commission Regulation (EU) No 651/2014 of 17 June 2014 declaring certain categories of aid compatible with the internal market in application of Articles 107 and 108 of the Treaty (consolidated version) [2023] OJ L 167.
  42. Commission Regulation (EU) No. 2023/1315 of 23 June 2023 amending Regulation (EU) No. 651/2014 declaring certain categories of aid compatible with the internal market in application of Articles 107 and 108 of the Treaty and Regulation (EU) No. 2022/2473 declaring certain categories of aid to undertakings active in the production, processing and marketing of fshery and aquaculture products compatible with the internal market in application of Articles 107 and 108 of the Treaty [2023] OJ L 167/1.
  43. Commission Regulation (EU) No. 651/2014 of 17 June 2014 declaring certain categories of aid compatible with the internal market in application of Articles 107 and 108 of the Treaty (consolidated version) [2023] OJ L 167/1.
  44. Communication Communication from the Commission to the European Parliament, the European Council, the Council, the European Economic and Social Committee, and the Committee of the Regions of 8 March 2022 on REPowerEU: Joint European Action for more affordable, secure and sustainable energy, COM(2022) 108 final.
  45. Communication from the Commission to the European Parliament, the European Council, the Council, the European Economic and Social Committee, and the Committee of the Regions of 11 December 2019 The European Green Deal, COM(2019) 640 final.
  46. Communication from the Commission to the European Parliament, the Council, the European Economic and Social Committee, and the Committee of the Regions of 8 May 2012 EU State Aid Modernisation, COM(2012)209 final.
  47. Communication from the Commission, Framework for State aid for research and development and innovation 2022 [2022] OJ C 414/1.
  48. Communication from the Commission, Guidelines on regional State Aid [2021] OJ C 153/1.
  49. Communication from the Commission, Guidelines on State aid for climate, environmental protection and energy 2022 [2022] OJ C 80/1.
  50. Communication from the Commission, Guidelines on State aid for environmental protection and energy 2014–2020 [2020] OJ C 200/1.
  51. Communication from the Commission, Temporary Crisis and Transition Framework for State Aid measures to support the economy following the aggression against Ukraine by Russia [2022] OJ C 131/1.
  52. Communication from the Commission, Temporary Framework for State aid measures to support the economy in the current COVID-19 outbreak [2020] OJ C 91/1.
  53. Cross B., Climate Change and the Politics of Apocalyptic Redirection, 21(2) Political Studies Review 223 (2023), pp. 223–237.
  54. De Marez K., Pielmus A-M., Key Elements of the Revised Guidelines on Regional State Aid, 21(2) European State Aid Law Quarterly 120 (2022), pp. 120–131.
  55. Dechezleprêtre A., Sato M., The Impacts of Environmental Regulations on Competitiveness, 11(2) Review of Environmental Economics and Policy 183 (2017), pp. 183–206.
  56. Directive (EU) 2003/87/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council of 13 October 2003 establishing a scheme for greenhouse gas emission allowance trading within the Community and amending Council Directive 96/61/EC, Directive 2003/87/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council of 13 October 2003 establishing a scheme for greenhouse gas emission allowance trading within the Community and amending Council Directive 96/61/EC [2003] OJ L 275/32.
  57. Ergen T., Schmitz L., The Sunshine Problem: Climate Change and Managed Decline in the European Union, 23(6) MPIfG Discussion Paper 1 (2023), pp. 1–23.
  58. EU Climate Policy After the Crisis, 23(1) Environmental Politics 1 (2014), pp. 1–17.
  59. European Commission, Commission Staff Working Document Accompanying the Document Report from the Commission Report on Competition Policy 2022, Brussels, 4 April 2023, COM(2023) 184 final, especially Annex II.
  60. Evans L., Nyssens H., Economics in State Aid: Soon as Routine as Dentistry?, in: A.M. Mateus, T. Moreira (eds.), Competition Law and Economics: Advances in Competition Policy Enforcement in the EU and North America, Edward Elgar Publishing, Cheltenham: 2010, pp. 363–381.
  61. Gràcia N., Lunneryd I., Papaefthymiou A., The Race Towards a More Sustainable Future: Is Current State Aid Policy Fit for Purpose?, 8(2) Competition Law & Policy Debate 92 (2023), pp. 92–100.
  62. Gunningham N., Environment Law, Regulation and Governance: Shifting Architectures, 21(2) Journal of Environmental Law 179 (2009), pp. 179–212.
  63. Harcourt G.C., Karmel P.H., Wallace R.H., Economic Activity, Cambridge University Press, New York: 1967.
  64. Heimler A., State Aid Control: Recent Developments and Some Remaining Challenges, in: P.L. Parcu, G. Monti, M. Botta (eds.), EU State Aid Law: Emerging Trends at the National and EU Levels, Edward Elgar Publishing, Cheltenham: 2020, pp. 54–69.
  65. Joined Cases C-73/22 P and C-77/22 P Grupa Azoty S.A. and Others v. European Commission, EU:C:2023:570.
  66. Joined Cases T-226/09 and T-230/09 British Telecommunications plc (T-226/09) and BT Pension Scheme Trustees Ltd (T-230/09) v European Commission, EU:T:2013:466.
  67. Joined Cases T-228/99 and T-233/99 Westdeutsche Landesbank Girozentrale and Land NordrheinWestfalen v. Commission of the European Communities, EU:T:2003:57.
  68. Joined Cases T-81/07, T-82/07 and T-83/07 Jan Rudolf Maas and Others v. Commission of the European Communities, EU:T:2009:237.
  69. Kassim H., Lyons B., The New Political Economy of EU State Aid Policy, 13(1) Journal of Industry, Competition and Trade 1 (2013), pp. 1–21.
  70. Lehmann P., Justifying a Policy Mix for Pollution Control: A Review of Economic Literature, 26(1) Journal of Economic Surveys 71 (2012), pp. 71–97.
  71. Leipold S., Transforming Ecological Modernization “From Within” or Perpetuating It? The Circular Economy as EU Environmental Policy Narrative, 30(6) Environmental Politics 1045 (2021), pp. 1045–1067.
  72. Lemonnier V., The EU Green Deal Industrial Plan, 22(2) European State Aid Law Quarterly 123 (2023), pp. 123–131.
  73. Leoncini R., Marzucchi A., Montresor S., Rentochini F., “Better Late Than Never”: The Interplay Between Green Technology and Age For Firm Growth, 52(4) Small Business Economics 891 (2019), pp. 891–904.
  74. Naegele H., Zaklan A., Does the EU ETS Cause Carbon Leakage in European Manufacturing?, 93 Journal of Environmental Economics and Management 125 (2019), pp. 125–147.
  75. Nicolaides P., The Incentive Effect of State Aid: Its Meaning, Measurement, Pitfalls and Application, 4 World Competition 579 (2009), pp. 579–591.
  76. Pianta M., Lucchese M., Rethinking the European Green Deal: An Industrial Policy for a Just Transition in Europe, 52(4) Review of Radical Political Economics 633 (2020), pp. 633–641.
  77. Piernas López J.L., The Concept of State Aid Under EU Law: From Internal Market to Competition and Beyond, Oxford University Press, Oxford: 2015.
  78. Ramos-Pérez D., State Aid to Airlines in Spain: An Assessment of Regional and Local Government Support from 1996 to 2014, 49 Transport Policy 137 (2014), pp. 137–147.
  79. Raz J., The Concept of a Legal System, Oxford University Press, Oxford: 1980.
  80. Remarks by Executive Vice-President Vestager on the proposal for a State aid Temporary Crisis and Transition Framework, European Commission, 1 February 2023, available at: https://ec.europa.eu/commission/presscorner/detail/en/SPEECH_23_527 (accessed 30 August 2024).
  81. Ricketts M., Peacock A., Bargaining and the Regulatory System, 6(1) International Review of Law and Economics 3 (1986), pp. 3–16.
  82. Rodrigues R., Pietzcker R., Fragkos P., Price J., McDowall W., Siskos P., Fotiou T., Luderer G., Capros P., Narrative-Driven Alternative Roads to Achieve Mid-Century CO2 Net Neutrality in Europe, 239(A) Energy 1 (2022), pp. 1–17.
  83. Ryznar M., Woody K.E., A Framework on Mandating Versus Incentivizing Corporate Social Responsibility, 98 Marquette Law Review 1667 (2015), pp. 1667–1694.
  84. Sappington D., Designing Incentive Regulation, 9(3) Review of Industrial Organization 245 (1994), pp. 245–272.
  85. Schroder C., Industrielle Arbeitskosten im internationalen Vergleich, 43(3) IW-Trends – Vierteljahresschrift zur Empirischen Wirtschaftsforsc 39 (2016), pp. 39–57.
  86. Soderholm P., The Green Economy Transition: The Challenges of Technological Change for Sustainability, 3(6) Sustainable Earth 1 (2020), pp. 1–11.
  87. State aid – Germany – State aid C 34/2006 (ex N 29/2005) – Introduction of digital terrestrial television (DVB-T) in North Rhine-Westphalia – Invitation to submit comments pursuant to Article 88(2) of the EC Treaty [2007] OJ C 204/9.
  88. State aid – Hungary – State aid SA.48556 (2019/C) – Regional investment aid to Samsung SDI – Invitation to submit comments pursuant to Article 108(2) of the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union [2022] OJ C 82/21.
  89. State aid Scoreboard 2023, European Commission, 9 April 2024, available at: https://competition-policy.ec.europa.eu/document/download/0b2037c5-c43f-4917-b654-f48f74444015_en?flename=state_aid_scoreboard_note_2023.pdf (accessed 30 August 2024).
  90. State aid: Commission adopts Temporary Crisis Framework to support the economy in context of Russia’s invasion of Ukraine, European Commission, 23 March 2022, available at: https://ec.europa.eu/commission/presscorner/detail/en/statement_22_1949 (accessed 30 August 2024).
  91. Ştefan O., Soft Law in Court: Competition Law, State Aid, and the Court of Justice of the European Union, Wolters Kluwer, Den Haag: 2013.
  92. Stuart T.E., Roginska-Green I., Sixty Years of EU State Aid Law and Policy: Analysis and Assessment, Wolters Kluwer, Alphen aan den Rijn: 2018.
  93. Sunstein C., The Paradoxes of the Regulatory State, 57 University of Chicago Law Review 407 (1990), pp. 407–441.
  94. TCTF/RRF - Slovakia: Investment support for electricity storage, available at: https://competition-cases.ec.europa.eu/cases/SA.106554 (accessed 30 August 2024).
  95. Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union [2022] OJ C 357/1.
  96. Vogelsang I., Incentive Regulation and Competition in Public Utility Markets: A 20-Year Perspective, 22(1) Journal of Regulatory Economics 5 (2002), pp. 5–27.
  97. Werner P., Verouden V. (eds.), EU State Aid Control: Law and Economics, Wolters Kluwer, Alphen aan den Rijn: 2016.

Similar Articles

You may also start an advanced similarity search for this article.